|Reviews for Ash's Comet|
| Rebse chapter 1 . 10/13/2013
I don't think you will read this but, however, I wanted to give you some feedback because you will always be my favorite author in this fandom. "A Farewell to Arms" is the best story to Banana Fish I've ever read and this here is the second one. Indeed, the longer alternate fanfiction is the happier one. "Ash's Comet" is just so damn sad. Even after years, only with the imagination of this situation I feel my heart sink. I really love this short text, and I really hate it somehow. Thank you for your wonderful stories.
| Ii chapter 1 . 8/18/2012
This is beautiful. Very sad and bittersweet. Really good fic from Banana Fish.
| Tsukishiro Yuu chapter 1 . 2/28/2011
Great, lol, i just can't think of the right words , but it was great.I mean you just made me cry XD
Thank you for writhing it, really.
| Sunfalling chapter 1 . 6/30/2009
Ah, this is really lovely. There's such understated emotion here. It grabbed my heart when Ash said, "Don’t make me live that long. I can’t. Not even for you."
It's thanks to you that I had to re-read the entire series and start working on my long, Sing-centric fic. Argh. I blame you for my obsession!
| Yukino S chapter 1 . 6/10/2009
What a beautiful story!
I was very impressed.