|Reviews for A Shadow Called Sirius|
| andvellapaz chapter 1 . 8/3/2011
this made me cry so hard
| dork-with-glasses chapter 1 . 3/15/2010
This was amazing. I didn't think Remus was out of character at all, because if you thought your best friend got your other three best friends killed then you'd be livid. This was amazing, I loved your description of Azkaban and the cells and just the feeling of the place, it was amazing. The whole story was. Marvellous work.
| breeutiful chapter 1 . 2/12/2010
Remus' anger was definitely justified. You managed to build up all this tension in the fic until it snapped (excellently, mind you :D) with Remus shouting. I loved this! :D
| Silver Sailor Ganymede chapter 1 . 2/6/2010
'he’ll grow up an orphan, not understanding who he is until he’s twelve' - actually Harry found out that he was a wizard on his eleventh birthday. Other than that one very minor error, this was a wonderful story. I really liked your descriptions of Azkaban. You managed to build up a very tense atmosphere. True, Remus was far more angry than we normally see him, but given the circumstances that's to be expected. The conversation between Sirius and Remus was heartbreaking - Sirius really was a shadow of his former self, which shows why the title of this piece is perfect, very fitting. Keep up the good work.
| BrightMikal chapter 1 . 12/26/2009
Dark, and slightly angsty. An interesting idea, though I believe if Remus ever went to visit Sirius, he'd probably look into Sirius' pleadings, at least. Hmm... new plot bunny. Well written, and hope to see more of your work!
| Xxmgxx3445xX chapter 1 . 6/22/2009
I loved it.
First fanfic to bring tears to my eyes in a really long time.
Extremely well written, and I don't think Remus' angry is unjustified at all.
Both Sirius and Remus, excellently written.
Great ending as well. Makes you think a bit, if that was Remus' reaction there, how horrible would he have felt afterwords when he discovered that Sirius was not the traitor?
| Blouta chapter 1 . 6/16/2009
Well that was sad.
| Brok3nQuill chapter 1 . 6/16/2009
I loved it, absolutely loved it. I like the title you picked out, too. You really do have to feel sorry for Sirius, especially at the end. And I liked the way you wrote his cell. Great work.
| batman008 chapter 1 . 6/14/2009
Oh god this was so beautiful. I loved loved loved loved it!
| outwittingsquirrels chapter 1 . 6/14/2009
Oh god, poor Sirius, that's cruel. Really good obviously but...poor Sirius, especially at the end. Anyway, I really liked it