|Reviews for Hold Out?|
| nirky chapter 1 . 1/18/2011
In my head, they do meet sometime before Elphaba dies, but Glinda is her lovely, forgiving, longing self and Elphaba is the ever bitter and defensive one.
Like you, I hated Fiyero for meeting Glinda and never telling Elphaba. I take comfort in the fact that he probably didn't tell her out of anticipating the jealousy he would feel after seeing Elphaba's reaction.
| Riveted chapter 1 . 12/29/2010
I totally agree with you. When I first read that Fiyero didn't tell Elphaba about his encounter with Glinda I was livid. How could he do that to Elphaba? I like how you took the possiblilty of Elphie and Glinda meeting. It felt just right, there was a balance between Gelphie and melancholy. This was a well-written story. Thanks for posting.
| PositutitivelyEmeraldacious chapter 1 . 6/26/2009
So good! Love it love it love it! Yay for heart-wreching, miserable, un-happy-ending Gelphie...! I teared up rather severly...
| ProfessionalxDaydreamer chapter 1 . 6/24/2009
GOOD. I'm GLAD Glinda reacted the way she did. Poor Glinda. :(
But I really like the way you've given insight to Elphaba's thoughts. You usually write from the other side of the relationship, and you do quite well with Elphie, too. I love how you've made her...still in love with Glinda, even with Fiyero, and everything. And I liked how it's not a happy ending, because as much as I wish it was...it can't be.
So! Great job. A new story alert in my inbox from you never disappoints!
| Mirsha chapter 1 . 6/23/2009
This is excellent, as always. I like the way you've kept it realistic; it could so easily just slot into the book, and I love the image of Elphie asking Glinda questions as she holds her. It's a really bittersweet piece, and definately something I could imagine happening, plus I agree that Fiyero should never have gotten away with seeing Glinda and not passing on her message to Elphie! Nice work :-)