While I'm not a fan of the series, I have to admit that this oneshot is just downright AWESOME!

THIS WAS SO AMAZING! There was a brief moment when i felt like crying! You did an awesome job, really! I love the "The (blank) of Haruhi Suzumiya" parts) Great job!

i thought it was real and i felt sad

very nice, extremely insightful and it really captures her confusion throughout the whole story. extremely well written and the fact that you put the poem and her thoughts in so many different ways really gives the reader some powerful insight that ive always loved in a story, im glad you experimented with this, i really liked it.

K.M

This is really really well done... I love it :')

To, Whover wrote this masterpiece

Please i beg of you to continue to write these, words can't descibe how hard this story hit home, it literaly had me in tears by the end, thank you so much for writing this beautiful piece of art. Again, Thanks

i really like this its very orignal and i havent read anything like it

Wow. This is one of the best oneshots ever made. It actually made me cry a little.
Cheers to you, good sir/lady.

I'm speechless. That was an amazing take on the story.

It's so beautiful and heartbreaking to think that these characters we know and love could all just be the figment of a simple girl's imagination.

Brilliantly written, well done.

This is truly melancholic.

I really liked your story, and it explains some of the situations in the series, its a great fanfic, congratulations :D . Im from argentina, so my english is probably bad, so sorry if i have writen something wrong.

Wow. This kinda explains what I've gone through in the past, many times. Damn, I'm cryin'... This... is just... wow... And at the moment, I'm going through SOME parts of it at the moment, with my best friend, he isn't dead, but MY parents are telling me to stop thinking about him and go for someone else because he said we couldn't go out, but I can't... I can't stop thinking about him and I can't move on! He's such a dork, but that's awesome... He's smart, funny, we have so much in common, he goes to the school next to mine ['cause I go to an all girls' school :3], he's sweet, cute [which he doesn't know], he's... the most amazing guys I've ever met... 3

Wow...just awesome! Great job sir/ma'am. Just...stunning.

I saw a recomendation to read this story in the information section on a youtube video; and it's fantastic. It's opened a whole new branch of fanfiction for me to read :) You know how it goes, you're on the fence about reading fanfiction for a show you like because you're worried it'll be too weird, or wrong, or change everything the wrong way; but you take a chance and the first fic you read pushes you to either continue or retreat. It's like that. This is the first fic I've read for the Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya, and now I'm looking forward to reading even more.

And that probably all sounded so very random...So I will sum it up with : Loved the story :)

Amazing! :D This was just amazing. I love your perspective of the Haruhi stories and especially the making fun of titles ('The Posthumous Harlotry of Haruhi Suzumiya' xD)

Kinda sad, added to my faves..:(