|Reviews for Misfit in Middle earth|
| dauntlessofthesea chapter 20 . 6/17/2017
What a fantastic story! You made a likeable character that did believable things in Middle Earth. I love the realism you put into it, and that it didn't fall into pessimism and skepticism like so many other "rational" and "realistic" fanfictions out there. Honestly I think this is the first complex fanfiction that happens in Arda which I have read in one shot without stopping or skipping tedious details. I have fallen in love with all of Barbarella's kids, my heart broke for the two brothers, and you have reminded me of why I love Eowyn so much. Honestly, this was brilliantly well written. You have real talent. :)
| cjsl8ne chapter 20 . 5/7/2017
I just reread your story and I just love it! You did a great job on this one. Thanks!
| Alizes chapter 2 . 6/27/2015
Hey! So I know I am super late to the party but I just discovered this fic and I gotta say this is great! I absolutely love the idea of cleaning the king's rooms and Haleth thinking of singing to King Theoden. You have a great writing style. :)
| Hereward the White chapter 16 . 3/27/2015
Since Tolkien gives the language of Roham as being Old English, I've attempted to translate the ditty but only with a rudimentary dictionary and the result doesn't really rhyme.
And þæt rocket's rêad glær, þæt boms tôberstan in lyft
Sellan prûf þurh þæt niht þe ûre fana bêon gîen þær.
O âsecgan dôn þæt steorra-fâg segen gîet wæg
Ofer þæt eard of se frêomann and þæt hâm of se unhêanlîc?
| Hereward the White chapter 7 . 3/25/2015
And now the storyline starts to hot up.
| Hereward the White chapter 1 . 3/25/2015
So far, so good. Anyway I find it surprising that Meduseld's being described as a castle; really it's effectively a glorified mead-hall.
| twibe chapter 9 . 11/30/2014
Is there going to be any romance for the oc in this?
| The Farmer chapter 20 . 6/19/2014
This is a fantastic story!
| The Farmer chapter 4 . 6/17/2014
When I first clicked on this story I was expecting that your girl-who-falls-into-middle-earth story would be very mary-sue ish. I was pleasantly surprised by the quality of your writing and origionality of your plot! I continue to read it with great eagerness.
| TMI Fairy chapter 20 . 12/22/2013
A quite enjoyable read.
I liked the Northern Cousins.
| Cerebella Kennor chapter 20 . 10/30/2013
Holy hell this was fantastic. The trial scene really impressed me, how Aragorn used logic to win the case. And, oh man, when she was talking to him again and he was asking her how she knew Haldir, that whole, "there's a reason the Athenians killed Socrates," just about killed me! I laughed for like five minutes straight!
So yes, this was an extremely exciting story. I adored the friendship between Barb and Eowyn, and the interactions with her kids was so cute it was almost sinful. And, of course, 'kid' being 'baby goat' cracked me up!
| DragonOwl chapter 20 . 10/19/2013
| Redone chapter 19 . 10/17/2013
This is one of the best OFC in Middle Earth stories I've read. Hits just the right balance between knowledge of the future and using the modern knowledge. And the best is actually that it is not a Legomance, nor a Tenth Walker. Barbarella actually has brains and sass. Loved it to pieces. Am going to read the sequel now.
| quaff chapter 20 . 9/14/2013
This is one of my favourite stories. Thank you for writing it.
| WindyCorners chapter 17 . 8/14/2013
Great chapter! Yay Haldir's alive- I was so upset that he died in the movie. Poor Frealof, I hope there's some way to heal him. Legolas giving a thumbs up XD!