|Reviews for Cold as Ice by Sin of Existence|
| Penguin Thug God chapter 12 . 10/12
You started off good. Harry has new friends, gains Snape’s favor to get him off his back, thinks before getting into trouble. Than you somehow make Harry Matt and Luna do a Gryffindor... Especially Matt and Harry... I almost forgot that they were supposed to be in RavenClaw and not Gryffindor... and let the jackasses get away with everything...
| MarineAsashi chapter 12 . 6/17
Pretty f***ing terrible, you made him weak as hell and let the jacka**es get away with their bulls**t. F**k off.
| MarineAsashi chapter 10 . 6/17
| AstroNeko3000 chapter 12 . 6/1
will there be a sequel?
| kuraitja chapter 12 . 3/26
| Monster King chapter 12 . 2/24
Great story I really liked it good job writing the story.
| RatherFabulous chapter 10 . 8/26/2017
Okay, just no. I've sacrificed enough brain-cells to this wretched travesty. Bleaurgh. I could FEEL myself getting dumber with each page-click. (Ostensibly because you'd HAVE to be an idiot to delve more deeply into this dreck.)
| RatherFabulous chapter 4 . 8/26/2017
Well, I won't say it's TERRIBLE, but...well, okay, that's a lie. It's terrible. Quite terrible...although, if Enoby Way were to show up, this could be seen as a Purpose-Built Crap-Fic. It's certainly a valid theory. The constant repetition of "McGonnagel?" jumps the shark a bit. Perhaps the author was a "My Immortal" fan?
That said, you re-posted it for a reason, so I'm going to TRY to give this story the benefit of doubt and stick it out a BIT longer.
Thus far, the author is almost certainly a young boy who doesn't pay much attention in school. He's going to figure out the name of the transfiguration teacher eventually so that he can stop GUESSING, right? Perhaps he'll learn fact-checking as well. Pft, silly me, that hope is faint.
Really now, HOW do you HIDE a chunk of BLOODY MEAT the size of a SOCCER BALL in a ROBE?" (I think he'd need to have appropriated his granny's purse, at least, for that.)
Just...WOW, this fic is AWFUL! Is that the appeal, then? Oh, alright, I'll stop figuratively waving my arms about and ranting.
Well, we shall see...but only until I can't stand it any longer and stagger off to read "Browncoat, Green Eyes" by Nonjon to detox.
| TheUnholySmirk chapter 1 . 4/8/2017
If ur not going to be original about it, at least edit the chapter for spelling and grammar. Sry, that makes me sound like an ass, but u didn't even write it, so it isn't a time issue. Did u just copy paste?
| LandlessLord chapter 12 . 3/1/2017
Is there a sequel by any chance in the making by another author or what the f*** ever ?
| Guest chapter 1 . 12/10/2016
This is complete shit
| Guest chapter 7 . 11/27/2016
Owls are only in 5th year... it would just be grades.
| Guest chapter 3 . 11/27/2016
Good story. But the fireblot is not out yet, it doesn't come out until Harry is. 3rd year. The broom it would be better than is the nimbus 2000
| Guest chapter 2 . 11/27/2016
Care of magical creatures does not start as a class until 3rd year. Please change.
| Guest chapter 1 . 11/27/2016
One mistake blaize zabini in the list of names should be dead last. His last name is zabini not blaise, so unless you want to do all first names, please change that.
Otherwise, I'm really enjoying your story so far