|Reviews for The Professor's Discretion|
| archandincorrigible chapter 22 . 22h
This was excellent. You let the relationship build in a quite reasonable way. But this ending is evil.
| Cause-and-Author chapter 3 . 5/13
I absolutely LOVE The dialogue between Hermione and Snape in this chapter. It's delicious, delightful, decadent, and some other D-words that mean "fun to read and hard not to laugh at". Thank you for this cute tale!
| muumi2three chapter 22 . 5/12
After all that talk in - was it chapter 16 - about how you never use cliff-hangers, how could you end the story on such a note? I loved it - up till the last page - and I'm so ... hanging.
| madstoryteller99 chapter 22 . 5/4
This is an amazing story. I am in absolute awe of the powerful, rich, and nuanced dynamic you have created between Hermione and Snape, without having compromised either of their established personalities in the books. Often, it's so hard to read a story between Hermione and Snape without the two being forcibly placed in a romantic relationship and forced to act entirely out of character to get there. A man and female being close does not necessitate a romantic relationship, and I am absolutely stunned by how perfectly you have captured that. The relationship you have established is natural and complicated and ineffable, with undertones of friendship, inexplicable camaraderie, and co-dependence, and it's...heartwarming. I'll be honest, the sad ending was a bit disheartening, and yet, I can't fault you for it, because it worked. It was the perfect ending to a perfect story. Thank you so much for writing this story, and even though it's been four years, I hope you will soon write another one. I would absolutely love to read it. You are an amazing writer, and if you would ever feel inclined to perhaps talk to me, my username on this website is madstoryteller999. Thanks!
| Xiaou Nem chapter 22 . 4/26
Gah! Great story, but why oh why end it there. I want to read more - more I say!
Thank you for this story!
| Slytherin's Strumpet chapter 22 . 4/26
Lord, I've stayed up to the early hours of the morning reading this. I think I've just spent about 12 hours straight on your story, I'll have you know. And then, then! You have the gall to finish without a proper epilogue! I won't be able to sleep now, not without a proper reunion! To think, this amazing slow burn of a love story has has ended without even a proper kiss. Hahaha you've ruined me. No, but in all seriousness this story was superb. x
| Guest chapter 22 . 4/20
| Momorulz chapter 22 . 4/12
Y does he still die?!
| theladyofthelost chapter 22 . 3/28
Firstly, you deserve your username. Secondly, I absolutely loved your story... I cried on this last chapter, and I can honestly say that this is perhaps the best Severus and Hermione sort-of-friendship fic I've ever read. I loved it, seriously.
| Taedae chapter 22 . 3/25
I just finished reading this and ... my heart practically dropped out of my rear end. I am so stunned that you ended it JUST before we could see them reunite. This story had fantastic build up and realistic progression for their relationship which kept me invested in them to the end. It is my secret hope that sometime in the future you will write a sequel which will be all about their relationship because I am dying to see it!
| ebonypol chapter 22 . 3/1
| NYCUtopia chapter 22 . 1/6
Superior, fascinating story, with a masterful yet (for me) rather frustrating ending: i.e. I wish you'd written a companion piece on the (very long) delay that only she deserves, and how he might come to enjoy the present, and even the next day...
| NYCUtopia chapter 10 . 1/5
Wow. Brilliant idea, this detention with (against) the elves and the insight that follows.
| Nicky Gabriel chapter 22 . 1/4
What a wonderful story! You had a really incredible idea to re-write the last two books in a way I would like to have them. And I really like that you didn’t make it a romance.
| Guest chapter 16 . 1/2
Amazing story I thoroughly enjoyed it. Thank you!