Reviews for The Professor's Discretion
Shallallaa chapter 22 . 8/16
Oh my God, that finale... really well written story, lovely and slow progression.
Anon chapter 22 . 8/11
This story was amazing - emotional and believable (and that's pretty difficult with a snape/hermione fic). Everyone was in character and it was all so evocative. I loved it
ArabianDressage chapter 22 . 8/1
Firstly, I want to thank you for a beautifully written story. Your writing style was brilliant and imaginative and really painted the beautiful, painful picture you seemed to want to portray. That leads me to the story itself: absolutely stunning. It was, in a nutshell, what so many stories with Hermione and Severus aren't. You stayed true to character and let their relationship build in a very believable way. The only thing I didn't care much for was the ending, but hey, it's probably just my bias against open endings. Beautifully done, thank you.
Espied7 chapter 22 . 7/27
Beautifully written story, very true to the characters. I'm not sure how I feel about the ending, though, so I'm going to imagine up a closing scene for myself... thank you so much for writing. This is a masterpiece.
Ardent Admirer chapter 1 . 7/23
I can't begin to describe how much this story touched me.

I can try, but I won't succeed. Both characters were exactly as they should be - Severus Snape and Hermione Granger. Both of them complex and infuriating and beautiful. Morally beautiful. You have made them my favourite characters of any book I've ever read (although, admittedly, Severus Snape was already that).

My only wish is that you would write their final meeting, and not be afraid to make it emotional: to show their emotion blatantly. Because if ever anyone had the excuse to step out of character for one moment and - physically - show the strength of their emotion, then these are those two people.

Thank you so much for not letting him die that way, at Bellatrix's hand. I don't think I could have stood it. Thank you for not letting him die alone. Thank you for not letting him live alone. Rowling broke my heart by leaving Snape totally without allies. Even when he died, the only comfort she gave him was the sight of Lily's eyes in Harry, and that just wasn't enough. Wasn't fair. Then again, as he himself said, life isn't fair.

Your story is a triumph. If ever you could write more, extend this story, I know it would be a triumph, too.
Ray-Anne1 chapter 22 . 7/19
I'm on my phone or I would write a coherent long review.

Instead suffice to say this is one of the more brilliant fics I have read and absolutely loathe that ending purely because I am selfish.

I adored it. Your characters were some of the best I have seen staying true and you are a very talented writer.
Everne chapter 22 . 7/7
This is skillfully written, and I am really impressed at the originality of it. Also, kudos for keeping him in character the whole time.
audrmil613 chapter 4 . 6/13
,, ,
Ansy Pansy aka Panz chapter 22 . 6/12
So I was tempted by your writing to try your other fic and have now devoured that too! Thoroughly enjoyed it and just wish there was more of your beautiful words to read! Thanks for writing! Xxx
Wilcox tanner chapter 22 . 6/10
Oh my god! The story is awesome! I almost cried at thr thought of Severus dying again! But u didn't n i love you more for that! ;)). But should've added Severus's and Hermione's meeting. Plzzzzz. But i loved it! ; )
Clarine chapter 22 . 6/4
Merci pour votre fiction. J'ai aimé votre version de la relation entre Severus et Hermione, à la fois âpre et pleine de sensibilité. Beaucoup de non-dit entre ces deux-là, tant vis-à-vis de l'autre que vis-à-vis d'eux-mêmes d'ailleurs.
Merci aussi pour la lueur d'espoir de votre dernière phrase. C'est une courte mais belle phrase et certainement une lueur à l'horizon. Sans aucun doute Hermione vaut d'être en retard pour la Mort. Cette dernière peut bien attendre ; elle arrivera bien assez vite ;-).
amurdock42 chapter 17 . 5/20
NatNicole chapter 22 . 5/9
Best. Story. EVER!
NatNicole chapter 16 . 5/8
Effective device.
Love the Slytherin-ness!
NatNicole chapter 14 . 5/8
So far, this story is VERY cool and realistic.
890 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »