Reviews for Casket of Ardon
yummypie193 chapter 14 . 11/13/2016
Never mind, I guess you addressed the problem of his magic in this chapter :) I like!
yummypie193 chapter 12 . 11/13/2016
I like the story, but why wouldn't Merlin just use his magic to escape? I mean if he's the most powerful dude out there, and he knows the thieves trying to open the Casket are looking for magical people, so they already know about his magic (plus what they said in the chapter), couldn't he just blast them all away or something and ride for somewhere else?
BreathingMagic chapter 20 . 9/25/2016
Huh. Loved some evil bamf Merlin, one thing I'm wondering though: The bolt from the crossbow only ever touched the stone, so it never really did any actual damage to Merlin's body - certainly not more than the previous beatings did. So why then did the spirit or whatever you want to call it leave his body? Was it... Fooled, like Arthur and Tyson? O.o

Well I've read most of your Merlin fics by now, starting at the most recent ones, and I loved and adored them all. But your writing has improved greatly over time - well not exactly your writing, that has always been wonderful - let's say it's your characterization skills that have gotten better in better.

This particular fic, I have to admit it, doesn't really work for me. Merlin was being too oblivious with the whole Tyson thing and too cowardly beforehand, it just didn't add up and didn't feel right for me. I do not want to bash your work in any way though! I loved the whole idea with the cave and the casket and thought it played out brilliantly.

But the power of the casket leaving Merlin after he basically just fell down stumped me quite a bit and I needed to get it out - who knows, maybe it'll be resolved in the final chapters. I will certainly finish this fic since you have become one of my favourite Merlin author on this whole site and I feel like I owe you as much. :)
Guest chapter 22 . 4/29/2015
Type your review for this chapter here...
Patiku chapter 12 . 9/23/2014
I think that Merlin is too histerical. I understand that he didn't sleep in the night but after all the thieves know that he has magic so he should use it. They didn't even contain it!
Patiku chapter 2 . 9/23/2014
Well, it's interesting but a little strange to read about Tyson as Merlin's father, not Balinor.
Linorien chapter 22 . 9/19/2014
Very nice story. A bit strange with Balinor not being his father but I can roll with that.
Two things I especially liked about this. 1. Gaius having friends. I had to stop and think and I realized that even though he had been in Camelot all his life, the show never saw him interacting with anyone closer to his age. 2. You used the mithril excuse for Merlin not dying. I was very glad it actually was not his magic saving him miraculously this time. Well done.
wryter501 chapter 20 . 5/30/2014
you know, when merlin put that rock in his pocket, i was thinking along these lines - but i had managed to forget that, and believed the arrow had 'killed' merlin! so well done, author!
wryter501 chapter 12 . 5/30/2014
omg, i wanted more between gaius and arthur! i know arthur's in a hurry, but if gaius told him some of the truth about tyson, arthur would know he wasn't following merlin just to apologize for being a jerk (that's a nearly daily thing, anyway...)!
but here's where the rubber hits the road, too - as soon as merlin realizes the threat, there's the question of why not use magic to get away? at least one of the three, his father, knows about the magic already, so it's not keeping the secret that's a problem...
wryter501 chapter 10 . 5/30/2014
i'm not sure if the spell is cast on the room, on a particular person, or just whenever tyson is around? seems to me that arthur might figure this out after the fact, especially if he talks to gaius... are we going to see merlin more worried about arthur's safety with him not around, or the destiny the dragon goes on about?... we know he was ready to leave it all behind with freya so this is believable, but ... but... but merlin, you can't go! :P
wryter501 chapter 8 . 5/30/2014
seems to me he'd get a lot further asking for a short visit once in a while - leaving merlin's employment (destiny!) secure, and furthering his own plot about the cave and the casket...
wryter501 chapter 7 . 5/30/2014
this reminds me a little of the ep 'love in the time of dragons' - it's not often that gaius and merlin really are at odds... in that ep because gaius thought merlin was jealous of his happiness, and it seems to me gaius could be setting himself up for something similar this time - understandably, of course, but merlin might not see it that way...
xBookEaterx chapter 11 . 5/15/2014
I loved how Morgana is able to boss Arthur around... even if he doesn't admit it :p
Guest chapter 4 . 2/4/2014
This is SO good, just one thing, Balinor?
Guest chapter 20 . 1/24/2014
Oh no, not a reveal!
335 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »