|Reviews for Giving Up the Ghosts|
| Nachzes Black-Rider chapter 51 . 3/13
This story was truly beautiful. I am awed, inspired, and humbled by the sheer length of it (and the length of time it took to write!). I loved reading it, and eagerly await the next instalment of "Return to Romance" for my next dose of Nenya85 crack.
| Bloodyrose125255 chapter 51 . 10/23/2014
In a way I regret reading this story because now there's an empty hole in my heart...but on the bright side, that means that the story had enough (make that a huge amount) impact on me to make me feel this way. Hahaha, I won and lost this game. Anyway, I absolutely-positively encourage anyone who is intimidated by the amount of chapters this story has, to read it. By the time you're done, you'll wish there was more. All in all, I loved this story. It was extremely well thought-out and wonderfully written, though there were a few spelling mistakes that can be easily fixed. I do hope you continue writing such captivating stories!
| cuddlykids chapter 51 . 2/11/2014
You just... I finally got myself to read this and can I just say, my feels what are you doing with them. The characters of Yu-Gi-Oh! have always been so deep and complex, and as usual, you've handled them brilliantly. I love how you explore them so well. I especially like your version of Yami. Everyone more or less seems to get Kaiba but Yami is always different. In any case, I also really enjoyed the interactions, between characters who never did get a chance to meet. Or at least get a chance to say much to each other.
And sorry, I'm dead tired because I spent the last few (several, this was long) hours blitzing through this. Am I making any sense anymore asldkfjalskdjf I'm swaying in my seat okay I think I'll find a bed now _
| l.h.o.o.q chapter 51 . 2/3/2014
I cannot believe I missed the ending to this. Nenya, I... this will sound funny, but every time I would see an update from you, even if I didn't always leave a review, I got very happy. Kaiba is one of the toughest people to write, it my opinion. Making his character MOVE is difficult. Giving Yugi's friends their just due, I (sigh.) There's a reason, aside from it including my favorite pairing in the show, that I was always happy to see an update on this one. Congratulations, love. And thank you for everything.
| scrooge25 chapter 51 . 1/25/2014
It has been awhile since I've read Yugioh fanfiction. A lot of my favorite authors in that department have found other interests. That's why it was such a relief to check in and find a story I'm familiar with.
A Yugioh Wizard of Oz story where the roads aren't paved with yellow bricks but self-discovery. I've appreciated its blend of adventure, romance, and philosophical insights. I can relate to a lot of the things this story talks about. The rich flavor of living. Thank you for sharing.
| halowing chapter 51 . 11/20/2013
Another great story ending. Enjoyed the happy ending. You left some room for a sequel. Looking forward to your next story.
| Guest chapter 51 . 11/8/2013
Ooooo i can't wait for you to write again! Love this story. I can't believe it's finished.
| bnomiko chapter 51 . 11/8/2013
Funny as it sounds, I think this is the happiest ending you've done yet. Kaiba sounds about as well adjusted here as I've ever seen him, Yugi's got Anzu... and even though Pegasus and (poor) Noa are staying behind, Pegasus got what he was looking for and even Noa's found some sense of peace that feels a little more permanent than what he was left with in canon. There's really a sense of resolution here, the feeling that everyone involved can start moving towards their futures.
Or long story short, I like happy endings : D So thank you : D
(I'm not even going to ask for a epilogue this time, aren't you relieved?)
| AyaSeth chapter 51 . 11/7/2013
Congratulations on finishing "Giving Up the Ghosts"! It has been a fun ride. I'm definitely looking forward to your upcoming stories. Thank you for being awesome. :D
| Mistal chapter 51 . 11/7/2013
| SalaciousCrumb chapter 51 . 11/7/2013
...and so it's complete! In a lesser way than yourself I am sure - I am really going to miss this story, the updates have always been something I've looked forward to.
Though the initial ideas behind your tale were straightforward - the twists and turns of the plot, and the nuances you brought to the characters were incredibly intricate - and providing your work for us to read was a fabulous gift. I've loved it... and the way it all tied together at the finish was both fitting and satisfying.
I will always be looking out for anything you write, so am very eagerly awaiting your next venture, I'm particularly keen on the romance idea :)
Thanks so much for all the hours of pleasure.
| dragonlady222 chapter 51 . 11/7/2013
I am sad this is ending. I have enjoyed reading it very much. Bnomiko is awesome. It's too bad tha Noa had to stay behind, though. He and Mokuba could have been great friends.
| Sylindara chapter 51 . 11/7/2013
It's finally finished! I remember reading the first chapter as it came out for no reason than because your Newly Risen Book of the Dead made me love Prideshipping, and now it's been four years! I'm feeling nostalgic already :)
I will definitely be keeping an eye out on any new fics of yours, but dare I hope that Return to Romance is a sequel to this? Or that a sequel with Yami in the Modern World is in the works someday?
| SalaciousCrumb chapter 50 . 10/27/2013
Wow ! Sunday morning treat!
Somehow I'd missed the update notification - just went to re-read the last chapter ready for when it came... and there it was!
Loved the fact that it was Yugi and Kaiba who made the final winning play - in itself that says a lot for how far Yami has moved - and about Kaiba and Yami's togetherness, Kaiba could let Yami and Yugi save him... and Yami could leave Kaiba and Yugi to finish it... all very symbolic I thought. Similarly the Kaiba brothers fighting together - there was so much of this throughout the duel. The containment of Zorc/Gozaburo and destruction of the puzzle was equally important... now Yami won't be dragging it around any more - as a reminder or possibility - the past has totally been let go by both of them - ghosts at rest.
Can't wait for their return to the outside world - and hopefully the start of a new life together, shedding so much baggage should make it a bright and shining possibility.
Loved it as always. Thanks so much.
| bnomiko chapter 50 . 10/21/2013
I love that of all the monsters that you could have used to end the duel, it was Buster Blader that you'd picked. It seems so appropriate, even moreso than a Blue Eyes, considering it was the card Yami had chosen in his final duel with Kaiba at Alcatraz to show him the future lay beyond his hatred and anger. It's fitting that he'd use it to defeat both Zorc and Gozaburo, who represent both those things, and that the thing that was powering it was Kaiba's many sacrifices along the way.
In many ways the end of this duel (Ra refusing the order to attack) reminds me of Kaiba and Yami's first duel, where Sugoroku's BEWD refused Kaiba's order to attack. It just feels as though everything has come around full circle from where Kaiba had started to where he is now.
I'm glad you also made a point of noting that the cards don't work the same in the manga/anime as the actual card game, that it's the symbolism that's more important, given that Buster Blader worked a little differently at the end of Alcatraz in the manga.