Re read for the millionth time, I love this story so much, I can’t help but love these characters. I do feel a little guilt reading puckelberry again but if I focus on the characters and not the actors I still enjoy it no matter the heart break I feel for the actors.

This was good!
Sammi

Since a beautiful and unique story

I am absolutely in love with this story! I can’t believe I just read this

Just reread for the 100th time and still one of my all time favorites.

I like how you write it and what he doesn't relize is that she actually is the death of him

This is one of my favorite puckleberry stories, I've read it over three times, the only thing that bothers me is that there are so many different Hebrew and Yiddish versions of the name Rachel and Noah, I just think it would seem more authentic if the names in the earlier visions were along the lines of Noach (Hebrew) and Ruchel (Yiddish) especially considering a lot of the conflicts they have faced are religious persecution.

I really enjoyed this story. It was beautifully done and at times, truly heart wrenching. You made every incarnation of their lives unique and memorable.

Really well done. Thank you.

I sobbed. Dear lord, I couldn't stop crying. This story is beautiful.

Why? Why are you making me feel things at 2 in the morning? This story was gorgeous and sad and so very well written. I curse and applaud your skill.

This story was everything you could want brilliant

This was incredible. Truly wonderful. The plot was incredibly detailed and well thought out, and the story was written impeccably. Simply put, you are a truly gifted writer. With a few changes to characters and such, you could turn this into a novel. I'm serious. This is truly amazing.

read again today, prob for the 6th or 7th time total, still a great read. my puckleblerry has awakened again while wishing(hoping) for the pacey/joey ending, i will believe!

This was awesome to read! Seriously hands down the best story I have EVER.

I enjoyed very much
-t