Reviews for Brave New World |
---|
Jay chapter 22 . 2/20/2015 Please don't leave it like this! I just found your work and am disappointed you left this story like it is :( it absolutely amazing and I would love for you to continue it please! Thank you so much |
HowlQuill790 chapter 22 . 12/7/2014 I'm about to start crying tears of desperation here:( This might be one of my favorite fics of any fandom, ever. And that's really saying something because I've been reading these for years. I'm a new fan of the Blaise/Harry ship and there are very few good fics about them so you can't imagine how excited I was by like the end of the first chapter of this one. I find Slytherin truly fascinating, especially the lesser known characters and I think this was a great exploration of them. Also, Sirius is my favorite character so I typically prefer fics where he's still alive but you did such a good job expressing Harry's emotions over his death and still giving them a relationship that I didn't mind that Sirius wasn't in the story. And I love that you did a balanced level of Dumbledore bashing. It's been years and I'm still unsure as to how I feel about him so I loved that this displayed his mistakes but didn't make him pure evil. And Harry standing up to Snape...probably one of my favorite parts. I know Snape is technically a good guy but he's still an asshole who truly should not be teaching children, let alone the neglected orphan of his school enemy. Moving on to the old ways magic that you have going on, I love this. I read a couple of reviews that didn't like it because it was too religious or too cult-like and I completely disagree. And this is coming from someone who is fairly anti-religion and whose only cult-like activities consist of an obsession with fictional fandoms:). I think the old ways are more of a spiritual thing (which isn't necessarily religious) because I always kind of thought magic was a bit spiritual as well. I honestly don't know why I'm reviewing, you probably wot read this judging by the fact you haven't updated in 4 years. But I first found this story on archive of our own and it was only 12 chapters and was updated about 8 months ago. So I'm hoping that you still care about this story at least a little bit and that maybe se praise and encouragement will inspire you? Please? |
BeautifulCherryBlossom chapter 22 . 12/4/2014 What a stupid place to abandon an awesome story! Gah. |
Deb chapter 1 . 11/11/2014 Too much bashing, much too much Super!Harry, a ridiculously meek Hermione, Super!Hawt!Super!Blaise is eyeroll inducing too. Otherwise nice read. A bit unwieldy, which might be a reason, it didn't get finished, but ends on an extreme cliffhanger. |
angelalexiel16 chapter 22 . 11/8/2014 please update this is a really good story and I can't wait to read what happens next. |
Anonymous2020AccountDelete chapter 17 . 10/20/2014 I think you’re a good writer, one can really get into the events, and the idea of the story is something new. I remember I started reading this fanfiction ages ago and dropping it, not remembering why for a long time. But I do now. How should I put this... there are too many things that just don't sit well with me. The religious approach for one, like the morning blessings that Harry suddenly wants to perform because he read about it in a book. I'm not religious, so I really can't relate to such things and find them disconcerting. It also reads too much like a teenager falling for some kind of cult he newly discovers: Having troubles he thinks no one can understand/trauma, finding new friends who worship said cult and bring him into it, showing him compassion and being treating solely well by those people, while at the same time falling out with his former friends and family who he thinks don't understand him anymore, not seeing how he himself was not communicating his feelings/shutting them out, etc. Moreover, this cult sounds way too good to be true and Harry never pulls it into question, just believing every word of it - something that is VERY dangerous. The other issue I have is the "Lord" thing, since I belief in social equality. That is something like a step back into the dark ages from my point of few… Such titles separate a small number of people from all others and emphasize that they think, and that everyone else should acknowledge, that they are and deserve something better than the rest. For Harry pretty OOC, even when taking into consideration how much he wants a connection with his family - he holds different views in canon. Don't get me wrong - it's a good story. Above all the relationship between Blaise and Harry. They are the main reason I started this fanfiction and the reason I have read so far (I just love them). Your portrait of them is lovely and I want to know how their relationship develops. I also like the dynamics of Harry's friendships, even though they are a bit black and white. However, you started to diverge from that and I want to see where this is going. |
lilRoses chapter 22 . 10/17/2014 oh Please update! its been 4 years. I just read the whole thing today. I'm dying to know what happens next! Such an evil cliffhanger. |
unknown chapter 22 . 10/5/2014 just to let you I like your story but I felt like you are dragging a little too much. Also, you are making your story similar to others' story. The way how harry slowly start to not like many gryffindor and headmaster albus. |
Anankastic Eosphoros chapter 22 . 9/17/2014 I adore this fic. The concept, your writing style, your detail in all things magic, the slow build up. Everything. Although its been four years since you last updated, and I sincerely doubt that you ever will, you did mention in your authors note that you would soon be updating with several new chapters. Soon ended four years ago. :) I'm grasping at straws, I know, but as said earlier, I adore this story and would love to read more. |
DGfleetfox chapter 22 . 9/3/2014 You know... Ron really is a character I could do well without. Happily so in fact. And it's not just because of how much of a dumb inconsiderate jackass prick he is in this fic. I've always disliked him and cannot for the life of me understand why Hermione would be paired with such a dunce. Wrong move JKR. |
Salinia chapter 22 . 9/3/2014 Absolutely amazing story! Maybe it's in vain, but I really hope you will continue this story! Can't wait to read more! |
Istielrin chapter 22 . 8/8/2014 Have loved your story so far! The original themes and relationship with the Slytherin trio, not to mention the entire old ways concept, has left me quite impressed. I like your writing style too, of course, or I wouldn't have stayed up all night reading your chapters! Awesome cliffie - but I hope it's not the last we hear from you and that you find the time to update soon. Keeping an eye on this story on my favorites list ! |
kingsholto chapter 22 . 8/6/2014 oh look I was right.. absolutely crushed. I really wish you was finished but it's definitely still worth reading. such an awesome story. |
kingsholto chapter 6 . 8/6/2014 I can already tell I'm going to be crushed when I get to the last chapter before it was abandoned. |
Goose Girl18 chapter 22 . 7/4/2014 How dare you make this gorgeous story and then leave it on hiatus for almost 4 years and on a cliffhanger like "kill them all" you are a terrible person |