Reviews for Shiny and Blue
Akoulesblack chapter 12 . 10/21/2024
Love the premise and flow-starting to fear that it may be HarryXDumbledoreforehead glistening with sweat
Arithmancy Master chapter 73 . 8/27/2024
After a long absence from fan fiction I decided to re-read some of the stories I had put into favourites. It will be 13 years tomorrow since I read this story and absolutely loved it.
I was delighted to find that a chapter (63?) had been dedicated to me, after I had done 42 reviews for the story so far. (Yes I obviously knew it at the time, but had forgotten this as well as all of the storyline.)
It was slightly disappointing to find that I was the last person to review chapter 64 - in 2011, seems that so many people who read completed stories don’t bother to review the chapters, but just put one review at the end - if that. I enjoyed re-reading several of my own reviews and those of others.
I didn’t work out the clue about “put a ring on it”, just as I had failed to work it out when I read it before. So I clearly haven’t got any more intelligent in 13 years.
Good luck to you, in whatever you are now doing - I’m enjoying retirement.
Avatarklainegrindeldore1881 chapter 1 . 8/8/2024
I do have one question, why didn't you base this fic in 1916 when Albus is canonically 35 years old instead of being 76 years old in 1957?
LeafZeo chapter 1 . 7/4/2024
A good story, coming back to read it a second time. For new readers, just a warning for those looking at the comments. I want to remind you of 2 things. Number 1, this is a fan fiction. It is not a complete replica of the original works. Too many people are upset because things are different. Kinda the whole point of this entire site. Nunber 2, MAGIC IS NOT REAL! Someone a few comments below me is throwing a fit because you can’t transfigure things into food. Yah, in the original books this is true. But i also feel the need to remind you that there isnt a single person on this earth that can transfigure anything. “This author makes it seem like magic is op” ummm, i mean yah, magic kinda fucking is op. Its magic after all.
KimberlyJho-ann chapter 1 . 6/2/2024
what an interesting pair. thanks
l30rusty chapter 6 . 5/26/2024
you can't conjure food i recommend staying clear of this story its completely broken and what is written invalidates the entire story
l30rusty chapter 6 . 5/26/2024
why the hell not fix your eyesight you can wear enchanted glasses with other functions if you still want to wear glasses anyways
l30rusty chapter 5 . 5/26/2024
conjured and transfigured items last a finite amount of time and its impossible to conjure magical items
l30rusty chapter 5 . 5/26/2024
That makes the whole magical world fucking redundant it makes magic way over powered it makes the wizarding economy redundant and therefore makes your whole book redundant
ironhair chapter 37 . 10/24/2023
What band was it? Any one famous?
ironhair chapter 23 . 10/22/2023
What the heck
ironhair chapter 1 . 10/18/2023
Reading
yokedjaguar chapter 17 . 2/7/2023
Bruh... He was an Auror for how long and yet for 17 chapters he's been a cesspit of emotions, lust, and simply a weak blubbering fool. It's not even entertaining at this point. It's pathetic.
anyeshabaner chapter 72 . 9/29/2022
THIS HAS TO BE THE BEST STORY EVER!
SoulStardust chapter 72 . 9/3/2022
Just finished it and so to let you know, this was one of the finest reads I have ever come across, and let me tell you, I read a lot and that too quality stuff only.

Your thoughts are, well, influential. Albus Dumbledore and Harry Crockett are two of the finest characters. The most interesting one for me was Minerva young McGonagall anytime too.

This will serve as the perfect canon- compliant for me, given that some plotholes do occur, you did a wonderful job.

Let Harry Potter be cherished and explored as a character in the veils of Harry Crockett!

cheers!
1,762 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »