|Reviews for It Wasn't|
| silverhelix428 chapter 1 . 2/23/2010
Honestly, I'd have to say that we're not too soft on Samuel at all. The way Knepper portrayed him, it's impossible NOT to sympathize with the guy.
And after Claire's little stunt, I somehow can actually see this happening.
So, Damien, huh? That's a sick, twisted game for them to pull. I think I'd rather die than be forced to relive the ghosts of my past that way... especially when I was already in pretty poor condition.
My guesses about who the familiar face could possibly be abound. My initial thought was Peter, because even if he hates the guy for messing with Emma, Pete can't resist anybody in that condition. But that still doesn't make sense, because again, Samuel messed with Emma, and if you want him to let you live 'til morning, YOU DON'T MESS WITH EMMA. So then I thought Doyle, but Doyle wouldn't be that gentle. That narrows it down to Edgar, Claire, or Eli. Right now I'm leaning towards Eli, though I suppose Claire also wouldn't be a stretch.
Am I anywhere even CLOSE? Or perhaps I'm way off-base and it's actually Tracy. Which, if you follow the GNs, wouldn't actually be surprising...