Ouch. That ending made my heart hurt... Just a little. Wonderful story! I loved it all. You made me stay up way past my bedtime, last night. But in the best way possible, of course. Loved this story immensely.

IT WAS SO GOOD! Loved it!

I read this story all in one day, mostly in one sitting. I enjoyed every single syllable of it. When I read the ending, I got chills for a full thirty seconds, and then I burst into tears. Thank you.

Second time i read it, one word; amazing 3

It is a really good fanfic and I like it very much! Thank you for being such a good author :)

Have to do a separate review for this epilogue. Beautiful. After such a wonderful love story I was afraid to read the epilogue, but you did a fantastic job (with the help of Dumbledore) of making even their demises hopeful. (Sorry for the euphemism, still in denial.) This was sweet and absolutely wonderful.

Amazing story. I love how human you make both James and Lily. Lily particularly comes off as a 3-D character - although sometimes a creep. I like that her female friendships are shallow, that she's in major denial and that her rule appreciation is very selective. I almost cheered when James refused her request to date - knowing that he had to stand up to her or be a doormat forever. I can't believe you had me happy about that. Amazing dialogue, amazing character development. Loved this story.

I AM ON THE THIRD TIME READING THIS STORY AND IT IS GIVING ME SO MANY JILY FEELS MY GOD I CAN COPE

the whole thing was so great! A perfect mix of funny and sad. The end was so great as well, just tied it together in a way that was sad but also kind of comforting to someone who gets very sad about my OTP dying :)

I started this story less than 24 hours ago, and now I've finished it.
First, WOW. This was honestly a really REALLY great story.
I think my favorite aspect is that there isn't just a blind acceptance by James towards Lily's last big apology. The fact that she has to wait, and get accustomed being limited as just his friend for a number of months is really important. I like that she gets a taste of her own medicine in a way that isn't cruel on James' part, and it adds a lot of depth to their relationship. I've read a number of LEJP fics where it's like "I'm sorry. I like you." "Ok!" then a happily ever after, so this was a refreshing change.
The banter was really great! I was laughing out loud, and I usually only laugh internally over fic humor. I really admire your writing. And I apologize that you're only getting one review for me reading the entire story, but hopefully the fact that it's a bit longer helps :D
This was really well done. Congrats :)
On a separate note, I'm new to writing fanfiction, and I'd love it if I could message you (that's PMing, right?) about writing FF and talk about story ideas. I hope you read this haha.
Well, I'm off to your next fic!

I just read this in one sitting. Oops. Haha. It was honestly great. Thanks for writing it. I love that it was simple and to the point.

I haven't ever really taken James' side in L/J Fanfics. I am usually on both their sides. Like aww how sweet! They both deserve each other! But now I am all James! Lily doesn't deserve him! hahah But anyways, the writing is great! I love the story:) Great job!

In all the stories I have read about Lily and James, I have never read one like this. At first, I didn't like it because it just didn't seem like Lily would just shag some guy that she hated. But now I am not so much looking at her perspective but James'. I don't really know how to explain it but I love it!

It's brillant!

One of the greatest if not actually the greatest James/Lily fanfics I've ever read. It was a pleasure to read it. Thank you.

That was so beautiful and so so sad. I loved this fic. Thank you :')