Second time i read it, one word; amazing 3

It is a really good fanfic and I like it very much! Thank you for being such a good author :)

Have to do a separate review for this epilogue. Beautiful. After such a wonderful love story I was afraid to read the epilogue, but you did a fantastic job (with the help of Dumbledore) of making even their demises hopeful. (Sorry for the euphemism, still in denial.) This was sweet and absolutely wonderful.

Amazing story. I love how human you make both James and Lily. Lily particularly comes off as a 3-D character - although sometimes a creep. I like that her female friendships are shallow, that she's in major denial and that her rule appreciation is very selective. I almost cheered when James refused her request to date - knowing that he had to stand up to her or be a doormat forever. I can't believe you had me happy about that. Amazing dialogue, amazing character development. Loved this story.

I AM ON THE THIRD TIME READING THIS STORY AND IT IS GIVING ME SO MANY JILY FEELS MY GOD I CAN COPE

the whole thing was so great! A perfect mix of funny and sad. The end was so great as well, just tied it together in a way that was sad but also kind of comforting to someone who gets very sad about my OTP dying :)

I started this story less than 24 hours ago, and now I've finished it.
First, WOW. This was honestly a really REALLY great story.
I think my favorite aspect is that there isn't just a blind acceptance by James towards Lily's last big apology. The fact that she has to wait, and get accustomed being limited as just his friend for a number of months is really important. I like that she gets a taste of her own medicine in a way that isn't cruel on James' part, and it adds a lot of depth to their relationship. I've read a number of LEJP fics where it's like "I'm sorry. I like you." "Ok!" then a happily ever after, so this was a refreshing change.
The banter was really great! I was laughing out loud, and I usually only laugh internally over fic humor. I really admire your writing. And I apologize that you're only getting one review for me reading the entire story, but hopefully the fact that it's a bit longer helps :D
This was really well done. Congrats :)
On a separate note, I'm new to writing fanfiction, and I'd love it if I could message you (that's PMing, right?) about writing FF and talk about story ideas. I hope you read this haha.
Well, I'm off to your next fic!

I just read this in one sitting. Oops. Haha. It was honestly great. Thanks for writing it. I love that it was simple and to the point.

I haven't ever really taken James' side in L/J Fanfics. I am usually on both their sides. Like aww how sweet! They both deserve each other! But now I am all James! Lily doesn't deserve him! hahah But anyways, the writing is great! I love the story:) Great job!

In all the stories I have read about Lily and James, I have never read one like this. At first, I didn't like it because it just didn't seem like Lily would just shag some guy that she hated. But now I am not so much looking at her perspective but James'. I don't really know how to explain it but I love it!

It's brillant!

One of the greatest if not actually the greatest James/Lily fanfics I've ever read. It was a pleasure to read it. Thank you.

That was so beautiful and so so sad. I loved this fic. Thank you :')

No, it was nice :) I liked that after all that it was somehow... Easy? Like they slipped naturally into a relationship which was always coming. I think, at the end, it should be "he said sharply" not "she". I am sad the story's over though :(

It's so beautiful and I don't want it to end... :'(

That was a really good chapter :) I like the pov from Nina, although I feel maybe you took the easy way out with her not really liking him. It was simpler than these thins usually are. But still, good chapter :)