Reviews for Sam's Tale |
---|
![]() ![]() ![]() The story's back! Yay! I like that line about Frodo, "both younger and older than his true age" - that's so good. I'm curious to find out what presents Frodo gives out... |
![]() ![]() Wow. Right now, you're up to Chapter 29, and I am taken aback by your skills and imagination. You are a terrific writer! My favorite chapter was the one where you described Sam's tapestry. I could see it perfectly in my head, and I loved the extra detail you added to Tolkien's already-beautiful description of the celebration, like the breeches, for example. And the River...and in Rivendell...and in Ithilien...the list just goes on and on! I'm going to stop here, as it seems that I am running a high risk of gushing, but I was floored by your incredible story and keep it coming! |
![]() ![]() ![]() LOL...boy, is Sam going to be surprised to see that Rosie is right on this one and it's going to be a 'her'! But, that aside, how sad about Sam's family losing a baby. Really sad...*sniffle*. No wonder he's so freaked out about her pregnancy and all. I hope the wait won't be long till we see the next chapter! |
![]() ![]() RosieC, this is the most beautiful and sweet story imaginable! Your voice and vision of the time after the Scouring are so true to Tolkien's spirit. It's always a pleasure to see a new chapter. |
![]() ![]() ![]() I just have one thing to say... Sweet! Oh, wait- make that two... AWWW! |
![]() ![]() ![]() Awwww...:) That was sweet, tender, sad.. and I loved it! You just get better and better with this story! |
![]() ![]() ![]() Oh wow, you're updating more often now! I check everyday, and I was so happy to see a new chapter. _ Poor Sam, though! You're such a good writer... seems like I'm reading Tolkien's work. :) |
![]() ![]() ![]() How sweet is that. :) |
![]() ![]() I finally made it here. Wonderful job kiddo! No reason for any doubt. You have excelled with another little ray of sunshine. |
![]() ![]() ![]() I've been reading this from the start and just haven't posted 'til now but I just wanted to say WOW! As a fellow Sam fan (though my imladris name makes it more obvious) I love how you've portrayed him. That line about him and how he should have known it was morning sickness was just adorable! Keep up the good work! |
![]() ![]() ![]() AWW! Little Elanor's coming! Well, what did those naughty little hobbits think would happen, eh? ;) Awww... *goes off to wait for next chapter!* |
![]() ![]() ![]() Ahhhh..that's so sweet! I was wondering when you would get around to this part of the story.:) And your previous chapter was lovely as well.. Frodo hurrying to write the Red Book as though there was a deadline only he knew..*sob*. This story is wonderful, Rosie..Thanks for letting me know about the update! |
![]() ![]() GREAT JOB! |
![]() ![]() ![]() Nilly love, this is so good! I miss talking to you much-I sure hope you haven't forgotten about your little Kitzarina! _~ Keep up the good work-the pressure is on to finish my story; only 25 days 'till my birthday! :D Oh yeah-this has nothing to do with the story, but I got a duet in my school variety show. _ I'll be singing "Come What May" from Moulin Rouge. Yay! _ Love ya and miss ya oodles of noodles Nillyramiel-just remember to watch out for oliphaunts! ~Kitzi |
![]() ![]() ![]() Yay! Little Elanor is on her way! Sam's going to be a daddy! I'm so excited, and to think this is just a story! It is a definite nod to your work that you can write a story that makes someone feel this way! Are we going to have to wait long for Chp 29? |