Enjoying your story greatly, and so happy to have found it! One little point, though: LOTR is not set in the middle ages - it's closer to early Greece, or Egypt, or Mesopotamia., but even earlier than that. I know that would be a lot harder to write, though, and doesn't really affect the plot.

oh shit girl buckle up

OH MY FUCKING GOD FINALLY

I was CLAWING at the bars of my enclosure, i CANT

gonna strangle her for being so dense. WHI DOESNT KNOW BILBO BAGGINS, WHO DOESNT RECOGNIZE THE WORD "HOBBIT" AURGH

butterbur you angel of a man

i can imagine her flashbanging people with their reflections after this lol. being a cunt? boom welcome to vanity BITCH

this will be my first lotr fanfic, best regards from the naruto fandom, and cheers to a great looking story!

What an absolutely beautiful story. I binged it from start to end. Thank you very much for writing it and sharing it with us!

This is really fantastic! I was somewhat skeptical at the start, but to my surprise and enjoyment, I found it quite thrilling to read! Very well done. I'll be looking into your other work.

i have read this like 6 times in the last few years. it's always excellent . tyvm

haha, i get you are trying to illustrate emotional upheaval but your character breaks down crying, normal cries. or almost cries something like 8 times in this chapter. it's a bit silly. being emotionally exhausted is a real thing, regardless of the nature of your circumstance you, physically, can not keep up those levels of emotions, eventually you numb out. it is brain chemistry.

And she left all her family behind. Isn't it great? She could've asked gendalf to talk with god and let her see her family or leaving message for the, but nope.
Kinda hillarious that she had one goal for 30 chapters and at the end she was like "nah, i'll staying"

I really loved this story. I found Maddie to be largely relatable, and her adventures were fantastic! I was confused at first how she could blank out on LOTR for so long when she clearly found it familiar, but your non-explanation ironically made sense. I like that there is still a mystery to it. I enjoyed how she related to others and how disconcerted she was about her growing reputation. I think the only thing I would have been curious to see is if she ran into the Kinsleys near the end. But I'm glad she was able to reconcile with her former colleagues. And I particularly loved the slow burn realistic approach to romance. And as much as it hurts in some ways that the story ends where it does in the romance department, I think you did the right thing. She is the hope bringer, and you ended on a note of hope. it was beautifully done. Thank you so much for sharing your wonderful story!

Hello dear writer . Thank you so much for your wonderful take on the story. I've read it in one breath. It made me feel more then i did in years and it stopped the time for me, for at least a lil while. Thank you once more . Are you still writing? How are you dear author? Hope life is good and you are taking care. Dunno if it will ever happen (shy) but wishing you a lot of inspiration aswell, with hopes of maybe reading a part 2 of the story (giggles). Well, I will hope, atleast. Not just with the story but in life aswell. Maddie sure is a Hope Bringer (giggles, looking for tissue paper) All the best dear writer. Hope days bring more love and laughter and inspiration, yes, a lot of inspiration (giggles).

FelineNinjaGrace going ham in the reviews. The most unhelpful reviews ever and weirdly aggressive.

I come back to reread this story and it's fantastic. Thanks for writing it!