...Well that was a violent reaction. Thought you weren't going to overdo it?

Darn it, its so hard to understand foreshadowing when you've never even watched/read the original story. Its a very good story though.

I read this in a day and I'm genuinely so impressed by how well written this is.

I finished this story a little while ago but came back to leave a review. This story has been an absolute pleasure to read. You really lived up to your promise to make a 'semi-realistic girl falls into Middle Earth' story. Any future material on Maddie and Boromir will be warmly received xx LC

I absolutely loved your story!
It kept me always wondering and hoping and guessing! I loved reading it and I was sad for it to have ended.
If you ever feel like writing something more, or adding more to this story/world/idea, I would be thrilled. I don't mind reading pages worth of descriptions on how the build up the new world together.
Thank you so much for creating such a beautiful story!

I really enjoyed this story. Hope you will write a sequel. Thank you for sharing your wonderful story

I love your story. Thank you for sharing

I stumbled over this story, and I see that it's been finished for a while but I just wanted to leave a few words anyway.
Whew! I'll start by telling you it took me roughly 14 hours to read it all. Broken only by food and bathroom breaks. I was completely hooked from the first chapter. Need I say that I didn't accomplish anything useful today? :)
Seriously though, this was amazing! And you're really talented in capturing the feelings and personas of the characters. Amazing!
I'm usually not one for LOTR fanfics since they often seem a bit... farfetched or unreal, if one can say that about fantasy fiction. You did great with keeping it "realistic".

And by the way, you did the right thing concerning the pairing! ;)

Thank you for a wonderful story!

I really enjoyed this chapter. Thank you

Thank you for writing a wonderful story. It's great to read about an OC that is realistic as it would be challenging to fit into Middle Earth if you were from modern times.

I'd love to see a drabble where Maddie meets Ysmay and Bryce again! they were the first people she truly interacted with and I'd love to see her talk to them. this is my second time reading this story and it's just as amazing as the first time around!

Excellent story. You said at one point about how it wasn't as realistic as it could have been later on in it, but really you are right in that there is done sort of magic in Arda, in Middle Earth, and that to remove it through over-realism would be to change what Middle Earth is, especially in regards to the story of the fellowship. It felt just real enough.
It ended far too soon, but I always feel that way no matter when a story ends, and it was a good time to end it I know, even if I want to know what happens next.

One of the best character-development plots I have ever seen. Most, if not all, of the book fit perfectly and was wonderful as a whole. Thank you so much for writing, and I absolutely loved this.

A very inspired story to be sure. Near the middle of the story, it starts to go up and down as we join Maddie in her emotional roller-coaster that finally takes off full speed that had been moving sluggishly since the beginning of the story. The fact that she isn't overpowered or joins the fellowship is nice. I dislike the way the information Maddie had was shared with others, but that is a personal feeling and does not detract from the story at all. I am glad more characters survived, though I still think you made your character to dumb for her own good. The character building and world building was superb and anyone who has not written previously would be hard pressed to do better. I find the ending to be personally bittersweet, as it is the ending of one life and the start of another and is left open to the reader to imagine what comes next. I personally have never read the LoTR books, but i'm sure you read them many times just to make sure the story's information ended up being correct. This story definitely had a lot of love thrown at it by you and it shows through the characters and world that you managed to create and expand upon. You write very well and I am glad to have read this phenomenal story.

Oh thank god she stopped being one stupid dense mother f'er. Great story so far that i've read.