|Reviews for Black Dawn|
| Penny is wise chapter 16 . 6/17
| missgsmith51 chapter 15 . 4/16
Sinistra Vector? I thought it was Aurora Sinistra (astronomy) and Septima Vector (arithmancy), two separate professors.
Hermione really is irritating, and she is downright malicious on the subject of poor little Green Harry, who seems only to help and not harm. I wonder why she is so hostile and hateful. I suppose it comes from never having been a friend of Harry's when he was alive. Does she even have any actual friends (not having had Harry to run interference for her when he was alive)?
Why is Dumbledore so ignorant of these three "diplomat families"? As the Chief Warlock and Supreme Mugwump, I should think knowledge of their history and role in their world should be required. And yes, I realize it is a history for YOUR alternate universe; however, that shouldn't excuse Dumbledore from knowing it, as he is still part of your AU. He seems completely ignorant of the Blacks' place in the Wizarding world as well as how he has damaged things by allowing Harry to be murdered.
| missgsmith51 chapter 5 . 4/15
Well, since Harry's advice to seek help from Spike proved beneficial to Ginny, we can only hope she will accept his advice regarding the Diary. He should have told her to take it to Snape, who will know what it is. Then again, if he mentions it to Lucius, it might just get put away to be used for its original purpose. OR ... If Lucius and Snape truly want to get rid of Moldy, maybe they will start the Horcrux hunt. Perhaps Harry can check with Regulus and help them.
| missgsmith51 chapter 2 . 4/15
I thought no Muggleborns were returning to Hogwarts - or did that refer only to new first years? Hermione is obviously back, although I don't think it sounds as if she is going to have a very good year. (Sorry ... I accidentally touched the post button on chapter 1 before I was finished.)
Is Fai-lo actually Harry ... or some incarnation of him? (In the words of Vinnie Barbarino and some really super old TV guy I can't remember, "I'm so confused!")
| missgsmith51 chapter 1 . 4/15
I normally love Hermione. Alas, even when she is being portrayed positively, I will concede that she has some qualities and behaviors that would try the patience of that ultimate seeker of knowledge, Rowena Ravenclaw.
| moonprincess97524 chapter 16 . 1/22
Wonderful story. I do have to say that this chapter is rather confusing.
| moonprincess97524 chapter 7 . 1/22
Okay I know that this story is done, and I know this isn't a story for those that love Hermione. I have waited this long in my reading of this wonderful wonderful wonderful story, but what on earth is wrong with that girl?! Why on earth would she try and take a book from someone she doesn't know NOT knowing exactly what they are reading and tell them that she can explain the book to them?! Just how stupid is she?
| harrynginnyinatree chapter 16 . 1/15
Rather rich, Dumbledore preaching a fair trial for vampires to Sirius Black of all people. I was rather surprised that this chapter skipped so far forward, is the next story going to continue from here? Will you be updating the series soon?
| harrynginnyinatree chapter 15 . 1/15
There is no Sinistra Vector. There is Professor Aurora Sinstra (only one i, not two) and Professor Vector. They are two different people. Professor Vector as Arithmancy instructor wouldn't teach Spike, but Professor Sinstra as Astronomy instructor would.
| harrynginnyinatree chapter 8 . 1/14
You had said in a previous chapter that no muggleborns had accepted their invitations to Hogwarts after Petunia had talked to all of the families. Collin Creevey shouldn't even be there to be petrified.
| Lokiismylife chapter 16 . 11/24/2014
I absolutely love your stories and now can't wait for more.
| erik chapter 16 . 11/24/2014
A great new look into the background of the wizarding world.
| JDL45 chapter 6 . 11/7/2014
I still don't understand how the staff managed to survive the death of a student the year before without being held to account for it. Or why...
I enjoy this story, but I think there are elements of it I'm just not getting.
| kase519 chapter 2 . 10/6/2014
| kase519 chapter 1 . 10/6/2014