Well written. The plot kept me guessing.

oooohhh this was /good/

This was beautiful. Thank you for this work. I truly appreciate the read.

This was so well done. Thank you for this gorgeous story.

WOW!

It was a very beautiful story. My english is not good enough to write more but I had a very pleasent moment reading it.

this was a genuinly delightful story that brought back the feeling of when i first read the harry potter books. thanks for writing this

I came across this fanfic and it dawned on me that I had forgotten about that missing girl myself after she made her brief appearance. Then a forever of me trying to figure it out led me to... ghost plots and so much pre-planned and well designed material not being used in harry potter because its the direction the story went? There seems to be so much more to the "potterverse" that just simply never got written about...

The author, too, had disappeared from the site. I wonder, I wonder what happened to Paimpont. Authors have become permanently inactive before, for varying reasons. Is Paimpont still alive? Have they lost interest? Will they ever return?

Sweet Merlin, this is getting more and more chilling...

THIS IS AMAZING.

Okay, I have a guess: Was Sally Ann a time traveler? And that’s why everyone is so worried about her, and she didn’t belong?
Also, this story is actually doing a very good job at creeping me out, with the subtle yet consistent denial of an obviously real person.

Amazing story!

Wow. What an unexpected, bitter-sweet ending. Fantastic work!

i remember reading this once, a long time ago, perhaps even before it was finished, and it left such a deep impression. it made me think about memories, life, death, art, and how wonderful a platform fanfiction was. i'm glad i rediscovered this story.