Hey.
I'm too lazy to log in now. I'm not sure if I've reviewed this story before while logged in, but who cares?
This is, without doubt, one of the finest stories I've read on the site, in ANY fandom. You're brilliant.
That's all I have to say, really.

That was incredible. I can't say the ending satisfied me as much as I hoped it would, given that I loved the creepiness of it all, but it was a good ending for all that. I can't wait to read more of your work.

Ingenious. This is the best fanfic I have read in my life. I am beyond words right now.

I really enjoyed this story. The suspense was well done, the plot was really interesting and I thought the characterization was spot on.

I must say, I am wonderfully enjoying this story...I got on this site, expecting to sift through a bunch of the usual, questionably-grammared, shakily plotted romance stories masquerading as other genres, but instead I found this gem! I love the way you set a scene, and the way you describe characters that most authors would only give a cursory thought to. Also, the premise itself is sublime.
Wow, I gushed way too much...I must read more now. Please, never stop writing. I can tell you someone will always enjoy what you write!

I can understand why this has so many reviews. It's a simply stunning take on the Story of Sally-Anne. Beautifully written too. :) x

I enjoyed this. I don't usually really go for the "mystery/suspense" kind of stories; at least not where that is it's main descriptor for a category. But, this was a lovely story about a small and insignificant fact of the first book.

Nice story, but you don't really understand logic well. Hermione used logic to discover Snape's riddle and used her logical knowledge of the man to guess between the two choices. Logic doesn't mean not following intuition, your understanding of logic borders on ignorance.

Besides that, nice fanfic.

Tragically beautiful.

Really nice story !

I know you wrote this ages ago, but I still really wanted to tell you that it was one of the best HP stories I have ever read. The plot was fabulous and never predictable.

Love,
Kermitty

Amazingly thought out. Would have loved to have seen this go all the way in a sequel though with a harry/hermione pairing as it seemed to be setting up for here. _

That was beautiful. I cried so hard.

This story was one I'd skipped over before- I can't quite remember why -but when I came across it again, I decided to give it a try. I'm so very glad I did. This story was wonderful. A very sweetly bittersweet story. Thank you for the allowing me the privelage of reading this beautiful tale.

Omigosh this was so sad and it made me cry! But it was beautiful. I feel so bad for Dumbledore, and poor Ariana too.