Read it when it first was published and It’s 2024 and I still come back and re-read this wonderful fanfic.

Fantastic and beautifully written! An absolute must read if you’re a LOTR fan!

So loved this! Completely captured me with your brilliance of bringing some unknown stories to the words they deserve. Thank you!

This is the millionth time I’ve read this story from beginning to end since I first chanced upon it a few years ago, and it still captivates me entirely! Thank you for writing such a beautiful piece and I am amazed at the amount of research you must have done just to weave everything together. Absolutely brilliant!

I was going to try and write the story of Elrond and Celebrian myself but now I have read this one I don't need to do so. I loved it because you make us see why Elrond, bound by duty and responsibility, waited so long while loving so deeply.
You have caught the warmth and beauty of Celebrian and all the hidden pain and reserve of Elrond.
I simply loved this story. Thank you.

Why do you have to do this to me?! I'm an emotional wreck right now.

Love your use of the canon, you seem to have extensive knowledge and the elvish lines are perfectly sprinkled throughout.

Now if you will excuse me I have to go cry for awhile...

I love The Fall of Gil-galad! I was so proud because I was able to translate it out of the Quenya. Love the story so far. I never really imagined Elrond like this, and I think you do a great job keeping his serious and bookie personality, but also weaving in elements of fun and at times, weakness. I can't wait to read more! (So I won't...I'm onto the next chapter, haha).

I love the story you wrote about Elrond and Celebrian very much and I want to translate it into I share it with others in my translation?Though Tolkien said little about Celebrian,he left us a lot of room to must be a beautiful and smart women,in my opinion,and I love her,especially in your writings.(oh,I'm a girl)
PS.I feel so nervous to write down these words,but I have the courage...

I loved it! So cute!

Absolutely brilliant the amount of research that u must of put into this is astounding, the best written fic I have read to date.

I have three words for your story: I-LOVE-IT
It is the most complete, accurate and lovely tale of Elrond and Celebrian that I've rever read. Cheers for you. You're such an awesome writer.

This was absolutely AMAZING. I love how you really seemed to do your research and try to keep true to Tolkien's works. I got a bit teary in some of the later chapters, and any story that can move me to tears must be pretty damn good. This fic made my day. Hats of to you.

Again, masterful... sitting here in tears after reading. Wondering also if you have heard Adele McAllister's song 'Havens' The song always reminds me of Celebrian and Elrond. You can find it on youtube if you haven't heard, or can PM me and I'll send you a link somehow.

Masterful. Thank you.

"Rhovanion: would later be called Rohan"
No, actually. Rhovanion is west of Rohan. Rohan used to be known as Calenardhon.