Reviews for All my Memories Keep You Near
yankeehater chapter 1 . 11/6/2010
It's hard for me to read this story and not have a flood of emotion. I remember how watching this episode broke my heart. It all comes back to me anger with Desmond for using Charlie to get Penny back. Charlie's drowning did not get Claire and Aaron on the helicopter back home. Well, enough of my rant. This was well written, and I enjoyed it even thought it makes me cry.
Golden-Black Dragon chapter 1 . 11/6/2010
Wow. Like how you added something extra to the "Greatest Hits" list, seeing as it seemed a little bit contrived in the series. I think that Desmond was probably lying to Charlie, and that Charlie could've gone to the Looking Glass and survived. Claire hoping that Charlie gets back is actually remarkably sad in hindsight, because he never comes back...