|Reviews for Er, Do I Know You?|
| Saving People Slaying Things chapter 2 . 8/21/2011
nooo! ahh new poeple! poor ron hermione and the weasleys! pleaseee make him pick the weasleys over the newbies!
| Faceless Enemy chapter 2 . 12/12/2010
LOVE THIS STORY! CANT WAIT TILL THE NEXT CHAPTER!
| parselmouth05 chapter 2 . 12/10/2010
I got guilty about my less than constructive comment/review...
So I'm doing a more comprehensive one...
First, I don't think your characterization is lousy.
It's fine with me..It's not canon, but then, it wouldn't be called fanfic right?
Is Rosie/Red a love interest? I love competition...
I'm not gonna tell you to make it more angsty or more fluffy coz that's up to you...(but I'd like a lighter fic instead of heartbreaking angsty bitterness and despair...but as I said, it's up to you)...
Just keep up what you're doing... :)
I don't know if you've read "Lost in Transifiguration" in SIYE...it's something similar and yet, completely different...
Hope you weren't insulted by my shameless plug...but I couldn't help but notice the (slight) similarity...
| diagon galley chapter 2 . 12/10/2010
Hi! Brilliant fic. I hope that you keep writing. I think that him being with Red would be rather.. cute. Please dissuade me from that idea otherwise I'll be shipping the wrong couple in your fic!hehe
Update soon! Also, a question... how long will we have to wait till the secret about him leaving gets out?
| BanAnaRaIn chapter 2 . 12/10/2010
Great update! Quicker than Sweet Home England... Just a'sayin... I love the part about Harry working in Quidditch. Why did he give up on being an Auror though? I thought that that was his dream. What is with this Red chick by the way. Did Harry and her date before or something? Or does she just like him and he doesn't. Hopefully second option... One query... why doesn't anyone just tell Harry what happened?
| parselmouth05 chapter 1 . 12/5/2010
oh...what did Ginny do?
Great story...am adding it to my alerts :)
| Carola-x chapter 1 . 12/5/2010
I like it. (:
| Hushpuppy22 chapter 1 . 12/5/2010
This is not bad writing but a number of characters seem OOC or over the top, which makes me think it would be better as an original fic. Obviously Ginny betrayed Harry badly by falling for or sleeping with someone else. Not to mention the fact that the active, tough and high spirited girl from canon is now a healer instead of a Quiddich player or sports writer. That isn't Ginny from canon-it is an original character with Ginny's name. Nor is it in-character Hermione to encourage Ginny to deceive Harry in order to "start over" with Harry. This situation will only lead to more deception and eventually you will pair Harry with your Ginny, who is not worthy of Harry.
Change the names and you will have a good story.
| mitremlap chapter 1 . 12/5/2010
| bigmommak chapter 1 . 12/5/2010
Good start! Keep this up, and this promises to be an awesome story. You have set the stage for the reader. We know that Harry has been gone for 5 years, but that he didn't disappear right after the battle. We also know that something happened between he and Ginny that ended their relationship. I look forward to having him remember more and more.
One problem I see, though - conflict of interest. Wouldn't Ginny be removed from the case because of her relationship with Harry? I couldn't see any hospital, even a wizard one, letting that happen. The only reason I could see that happening is because of the secrecy issue. But, the nurse removes that reason.
In any case, I look forward to the next update!
| golfnjen83 chapter 1 . 12/5/2010
| BanAnaRaIn chapter 1 . 12/5/2010
What an original idea! Brilliant though still a little peeved that you have been working on this instead of updating second chapter to Sweet Home England... Keep it up!