Reviews for Tales from the Red Book
shirebound chapter 3 . 3/5/2003
What a terrific story, Eledhwen! And such detail, and love, and perfect characterizations.

"Dad," came a small voice. "Dad, can we do our bows and courtesies yet?" I do adore that line. And your meeting between the King, Queen, and the hobbits is just as I would have imagined it. Just wonderful!
MistressHolbytla chapter 1 . 1/30/2003
That was soooo sweet. Sniff. I read the appendixes and you did a great job of pulling all of the information together! Very accurate. Are you going to write more tales from the red book? Good job!
Sunsong chapter 1 . 11/13/2002
I could almost believe that I'd read this in somewhere in an Appendix.
jaffacake1 chapter 1 . 3/14/2002
that was really gd. ive red that part of the appenbdixes, bt id 4gottne lots of it. n it was sad. n i didnt cry, no of cors not. *coff, blush* 1 question tho. did merry have a son? i thort he didnt have ne kids?
Rayne2 chapter 1 . 3/13/2002
Awww.. That was good, but terribly sad!

Oh well, they died as heroes... which they are.

Good work! :)