Reviews for A Mirkwood Elf in Dumbledore's Court |
---|
smile7499 chapter 10 . 5/7/2002 hehe...i have finals! i completely simpathize with you. now if only i could learn to spell |
Jinx chapter 12 . 5/7/2002 Heya! We don't have any iceburgs here yet but knowing we will. Are you a Newfie or just a visitor? The Rock rocks! Jinx |
Clo chapter 12 . 5/7/2002 By the way, it’s actually ‘Earendil’ (don’t know how to do the accents over the ‘a’) not ‘Elendil’. In the book, Galadriel says “In this phial, is caught the light of Earendil’s star, set amidst the waters of my fountain”. In the movie, she says, “I give you the light of Earendil, our most beloved star”, HOWEVER the way she says it makes it sound like ‘Elendil’. Wow I’m ashamed that I knew that. *blushes* sorry if you already knew that! |
Jessica chapter 12 . 5/6/2002 Great story! |
Michele McNally chapter 12 . 5/6/2002 Aw dude...I love you so much, you know that? Two chapters: Yay. I'm on the edge of my seat, so post the rest before i fall off. Is there going to be more interaction btwn Harry Ron Hermione and Legolas? Hope so. Anyway, get crackin on the next chapter cuz i can't wait. Your faithful, Rynye |
Lunoria Moonwatcher chapter 12 . 5/6/2002 I love this story! This is one of my only reasons for getting online. You seriously must write more to this. It's great! |
Harriet chapter 12 . 5/6/2002 This is really cool. Keep going. Would you mind letting me know when you update? Thanks. |
Celas Victoria chapter 11 . 5/5/2002 Nooooooo! You can't end there! And poor Legolas! Evil, bad, ugly, dirty spider! I stomp on you with greatest of impunity! Anyway, good chapter, it's cool to see it from a different viewpoint occasionally. |
Cloudy Magic chapter 12 . 5/5/2002 Oh this is fantastic! Serious overload of Mary-sues had turned me off reading Legolas fanfic here, but I was just wandering aimlessly around the crossovers section and thought this looked interesting. I read a few lines, and was hooked. I've just read the entire 12 chapters and I'm so frustrated that I can't find out what happens! My first thought when we saw the unknown elf that it was Dobby - I know you can't give the plot away, but is that even close? But Dobby, Legolas' brother? *bounces in frustration* OOOOOOOO I can't belive how much not knowing annoys me! :) Back to the point - this story is far and away one of the best LotR/Legolas fanfics that I've read, and since I've read quite a few, that's a big compliment! The plot is incredible, the way you describe and switch from character to character is amazing. I love the way Legolas thinks, and the 'attercop' line had me grinning from ear to ear. The portrayal of Hogwarts and the Hogwarts characters are the most realistic I've come across on here, and the reassurances of no Legolas romance is a big relief - it's wonderful not to have any cliche Legolas-falls-in-love-with-mysterious-girl-who-joins-the-fellowship storylines. Oh dear god I'm raving on for a long time about this - but hey I've got a lot to say! As for the Legolas-into-Hogwarts universe - have you already decided how it happened? If not I think an explanation involving something to do with the pool in the beginning - maybe something about the power that had been in Mirkwood seeping into the water? I'm not sure what you're planning, but if it's like the first 12 chapters, we haven't got anything to worry about! Finally, I agree - Orlando Bloom is MAJORLY snogable! Keep up the great work - I'll be keeping an eye on this fic. Clo |
Rosemary For Remembrance chapter 12 . 5/5/2002 I read this while listening to "Lament for Gandalf." Music can really change your prospective! Very nice chapter I might add, I once took a character-personality test to see who I was most like, I was Galadriel! I imagine her best when I visualize her likeness in the Silmarillion. She's really cool in that book. Im also like gullum though, I love roots and beginings! Anyway, please keep writting! Namarie... |
Elf chapter 12 . 5/4/2002 Was the other Elf Harry? Wait, I shouldn't be asking questions, I'm sorry! But Holy Crap, this is great! And YES, I'd snogg Orlando Bloom! Actualy, *looks down in shame*, I haven't read all of the books yet that's how I'm picturing Legolas. And because Bloom is definately snogg worthy. |
The Elemental chapter 12 . 5/4/2002 ohhh. Spider venom is bad. I know. (Allergic to the stuff :P ) Another great chapter. Considering how this is going, I'm guessing you've figured out how Legolas got here, instead of the "Dimensional Vacuum cleaner" thing. Me like. A lot. Please keep writing, you're doing a wonderful job! |
krystaldragon chapter 12 . 5/4/2002 pbbbbbb. And so the story is finished for now. Gr. Ai, PLEASE UPDATE! I absolutely LOVE this story, and can't wait until you continue, please do! Until then, your loyal reader, ~krystaldragon |
Phoenix chapter 12 . 5/4/2002 Holy crap, how could you leave it right there? Spiffin' that ya updated, but you just HAD to leave us hanging... Why is he there, though? UPDATE! |
Laurus Nobilis chapter 12 . 5/4/2002 Wow! Two chapters! I really liked seeing the battle through the boys' eyes. And I'm so glad Galadriel showed up! I have a feeling about that unknown elf but I won't say it in case I'm right and I spoil it. We do get to know how Dumbledore's doing, right? |