|Reviews for Girl Behind the Curtain|
| Guest chapter 20 . 9/1
Great I mean GREAT more kissing like undoing her bra clasp
or something like that
| Guest chapter 7 . 8/31
Snog her, snog her, snog her!
| Amanda chapter 23 . 8/27
Just revisited this fanfic after a few years and I was crying for at least 45% of this. Your characterisation of Rose is the most relatable and honest I've ever read. I loved the bittersweet tones and the heart wrenching, maturely written ending. Love your work, always excited to return for more.
| Ensis96 chapter 24 . 8/25
I know this story has been finished for a while, and I'm pretty certain I commented last time I read it- but upon rereading I just wanted to let you know that it's still loved.
This story is short (plot-wise) and more about school and life than Hogwarts and magic, but that just makes it wonderful. I love reading how you gave Rose her character-development and how their relationship started. The one request I would have is Scorpius finding out that the 'heart-broken' poem she wrote was not about her own ex, because I think that would just be a fun exchange.
I especially loved the epilogue; I especially liked that it came from Scorpius's POV, since it felt like it closed the story really well. I would not like your story as much as I do if it didn't have that closure, so wonderful call as an author.
Really truly enjoy it!
| 7ScarletLies chapter 7 . 7/26
You cannot understand how much I love this story.
At first, I was like, "Huh. Okieeeeee, this is different ... Let's just keep reading and see what happens." And now it's all "OH MY MERLIN WHAT IS THIS MAGIC THAT MAKES THIS PERSON SUCH A GOOD WRITER WHY HAS NOBODY EVER DONE THESE TWO CHARACTERS LIKE THIS BEFORE WHY ISN'T THERE MORE OF THIS IN THE WORLD WHAT IS WRONG WITH EVERYBODY ELSE THAT THEY AREN'T READING THIS AND LOVING THIS AS MUCH AS I AM".
Yeah. That's my thought process.
| Guest chapter 24 . 7/26
Thank you for creating this story, you are a womderful writer!
| FlyAwayHero chapter 24 . 5/22
As a well versed Scorose Fanfiction reader, I must say this Rose is one of my favorites I have ever read. She reminds me much of myself, being quiet and observant while hopelessly falling for people. our Scorpius is absolutely marvelous and a perfect match for Rose. I've been recently researching MBTI types and I think Rose may very well be an INTJ which can lead to the best sorts of character, while Scorpius seems to be an ENFP. These types are near perfect matches for each other, which is why I believe you portrayed each of them so well. You did a most excellent job staying true to their characters throughout the story, each move they made was the exact move one would expect from their character. This is by far my favorite story you've written (and I've read quite a few, which are all fabulous). Love it. Absolutely love it. I've read it like 5 times, no lie.
| theletterzia chapter 23 . 5/11
You know the thing about silent readers? They suck. Majorly. So I've decided to stop being one, and to leave a long-overdue review on one of the first fanfictions I've ever read.
I stumbled upon your story a few years ago, when my conception of romance was still very traditional. But Girl Behind The Curtain showed me that there were a lot of paths that a love story could choose to take, and for that, I say thank you. And it wasn't only about the romance, here, there was also the defining factor of Rose and her own story - something that a girl needs to know, even if she doesn't go through it the same way. So yes, your story is beautiful, and I'm glad I've finally said it, even if you have long ago left the site.
| Pottergirl chapter 24 . 5/10
I loved this story, do you think you could write it from Scorpius's point of view? Harry Potter forever.
| Guest chapter 23 . 2/4
Beautiful! You did a brilliant job. This made me cry, sing and laugh my guts out in all the right places.
This end chapter really tied it all together. I appreciate seeing all the hard work and effort you but into this. I'm sad that it is over :)
AMAZING! PERFECT! HEART WRENCHING!
| rolygarcor chapter 23 . 1/28
you know in the beggining i was not a huge fan of rose's characterization. but by the end of the story i am glad to admit i loved her. the story was great and it showed growth better than most.
| experiencetoday chapter 22 . 1/3
probably one of the best chapters I've read on this site - so well-done, so well-done. Too often, many writers fall into the temptation of writing away an easy ending filled with empty words and routine motions - you did so well with this and I am so fortunate to have stumbled across this piece. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
| Iheartbooks394 chapter 16 . 11/1/2015
I want to punch Albus. Like, REALLY hard.
| Iheartbooks394 chapter 4 . 11/1/2015
Oh dang wow i love it
| ebdarcy.qt4good chapter 24 . 10/25/2015