Reviews for A Study in Magic
ChasetheDreamer chapter 20 . 3/20
This story was the best Sherlock Holmes crossover Ive ever read. You did so well to keep to the characters personalities as well as explore the possibilities of magic and the changes it brings. Ive always wanted to read a story with Quirrell being a smart confident soldier so thanks for that. I really didnt want him to die but I guess its for the best. I hope Lockhart could get the same treatment
xvector chapter 20 . 3/15
A phenomenal story. Absolutely impeccable writing quality, rivaling the best of them. An amazing plot. Your characters were very well thought out. This really is one of the best fics out there - in execution, writing, and plot.

A true adventure.
Smozzick chapter 20 . 1/25
Overall very much liked the story but it does seem very much unfinished - I would have loved to have read a sequel. Regardless I enjoyed it.
Smozzick chapter 14 . 1/25
Also last chapter at the end someone mentioned getting the spheres before what the treasure was was revealed. Otherwise good story so far.
Smozzick chapter 13 . 1/25
Hermione seems to briefly study Hermione in the...6th to last paragraph.
thepkrmgc chapter 20 . 1/12
yay for happy endins, heres hoping theres a sequel!
thepkrmgc chapter 19 . 1/12
well that was straightforeward...
thepkrmgc chapter 17 . 1/12
it would be really cool to see what happened to quirrel to make him this way?
thepkrmgc chapter 14 . 1/12
harrys still got to learn but quirrel shouls give ample pracice for harry to overcome voldys host's brains
thepkrmgc chapter 12 . 1/12
did you base the fics quirrel off HPMOR? its all the better for it
thepkrmgc chapter 11 . 1/12
nice job on the alternate origin story!
thepkrmgc chapter 10 . 1/12
its interesting to see the alternate take on quirrel and sherlockmort should be a very formidable adversary
thepkrmgc chapter 9 . 1/12
its interesting to see some of the logic behind albus's choice in guardians
thepkrmgc chapter 8 . 1/12
the sorting scene was rather amusing, nice insight about the nature of the hat
thepkrmgc chapter 7 . 1/12
nice job using cannon events to better develop the young detectives character, he's a shoe in for ravenclaw
747 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »