| Reviews for A Study in Magic |
|---|
   wilfredo.retamal chapter 20 . 9/22 That was... Highly anticlimatic. Not a bad story by itself, but I feel like you could've been somewhat more ambitious with it. It does leave you a bittersweet aftertaste. The setting and characters were interesting, but the last two chapters... It just didn't work for me. |
| lGrl0hwI9pfg8YLidY42 chapter 8 . 9/18 This chapter was good! The hat's personality was interestingly done. It seems to have taken some inspiration from HPMoR or a story inspired by HPMoR, but it is by no means a copy. |
| sam.zweighaft chapter 1 . 9/16 YES YES YES THE GAME IS AFOOT! |
| Guest chapter 10 . 7/19 ...what? |
| Guest chapter 3 . 7/19 HE HAS FUCKIN DETECTIVE MODE! I CANT WAIT FOR HOGWARTS |
| Guest chapter 1 . 7/19 this is gonna be good huh? im lovin it like mcdonalds man |
| Guest chapter 1 . 7/12 You have not explained why Dumbledore is leaving harry with sherlock. i hope you will soon. |
| naejeiuol04 chapter 8 . 6/5 Grindelwald's from Durmstrang |
| GBTtown chapter 20 . 5/19 While complete in and of itself, I always wanted more of this story. It is one of the best sh/hp crossovers I have ever come across. Very enjoyable. |
| dreamflower02 chapter 20 . 4/15 What an utterly brilliant and self-contained story! |
| ScruffydaDruid chapter 20 . 2/25 Damn. This is fantastic. Quite possibly the best fanfic I've ever read. I especially loved the 'excerpts from a Study of Magic by John Watson'. They were awesome and often hilarious and I felt like I was reading a Sherlock Holmes novel. This is just a genuinely incredible story and I'm so glad that I read it. |
| AkaDeca chapter 7 . 2/11 Elementary. I LOVE IT |
| AkaDeca chapter 6 . 2/11 Loved this chapter |
| AkaDeca chapter 4 . 1/28 This was such a beautifully well made chapter. This story better not be abandoned! |
| Naomi chapter 1 . 11/15/2017 Brilliant! Loved every sentence. Too bad there isnt more! |