|Reviews for A Study in Magic|
| Kittens Kat chapter 20 . 3/11
THIS WAS REALLY WELL DONE AND I TRULY LIKE YOUR WRITING STYLE! THANK YOU!
| Kisaki Sakura chapter 20 . 3/4
Amazing. Two of the best fandoms united in an absolut astonishing manner.
| PiptheSnake chapter 20 . 3/2
I actually quite enjoyed that; it was far better than I was expecting it to be, and had just the right amount of the right type of humour (i.e. the conversation with the Hat) and was brilliantly written.
I'm really glad I read it; thanks for posting
| Guest chapter 20 . 2/14
| OMSdigifan64 chapter 20 . 2/9
Awesome story :)
| Guest chapter 4 . 2/2
Well done. Chapters seem a little short but it is well written and everyone is in character. I highly recommend Harry Potter and the Methods of Rationality if you have not read it already.
| Osmodious chapter 20 . 1/29
Very nicely done...very disappointed you are not going to continue as this is well written (hinting at Doyle's style quite well), interesting, full of interesting ideas on magic and non-magic and just plain fun to read. The aphorisms, for want of a better term, are wonderful as well...each is an excellent lesson in a phrase, and your development of many of them through exposition of an 'experience' is just great. Thanks for posting!
| moonclan88 chapter 20 . 1/22
WHYD YOU KILL QUIRREL! I liked this Quirrel the defense spots isn't cursed!*glares heavily at author
| R. Howard Lawrence chapter 20 . 1/17
Just finished this and words fail me
Thank You again
| R. Howard Lawrence chapter 1 . 1/17
I found this in October 2013 and finally got around to reading it and just finished the first chapter.
Marvelously Brilliant in conception and execution so far.
I do hope the trend continues to the finish.
Thank You for the most welcome read of 2014 for me
| Sun-Tsu Toriden chapter 5 . 1/13
Harry's new chest reminds me mightily of Rincewind's Luggage.
Less several hundred feet and murderous intent, of course.
Also, what sort of time period is this set in? You mentioned a digital watch and refrigerator, yet both Holmes and Watson use methods of speech and mannerisms more suited to their original turn-of-the-century setting. Also, few doctors go so far away to visit patients anymore, as was commonly the case in Doyle's day.
| Ikurus chapter 1 . 12/25/2013
Thank you for writing and sharing.
| Abderan Sophist chapter 20 . 12/15/2013
The ending seems somehow a little abrupt, but other than that I really enjoyed this one!
| MuggleRavenclaw chapter 20 . 12/9/2013
Fantastic work. This read very much like a classic Sherlock Holmes short story. I was impressed, though, that you managed to avoid sending a miniature Holmes to Hogwarts. Harry was definitely his own person, even with his deductive talents. I loved the concept of Neville in Ravenclaw. I don't believe I have ever seen that before, but you made it plausible. There were a few typos, and technically, Luna shouldn't have been at Hogwarts yet; but I can easily overlook small things like that. In all, I was very entertained.
| MuggleRavenclaw chapter 1 . 12/9/2013
I just happened to stumble across this and I must say, I'm quite excited about this story. I've seen a few attempted HP/Holmes crossovers, but they never turned out well. The main reason for this is that the writer usually tried to write the character of Sherlock Holmes with their own writing style, and that never works. Based off of this chapter, you seem able to write very nicely in the style of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, so I have very high hopes for this fic. I will probably leave another review when I get to the end to let you know what I thought.