|Reviews for but with a whimper|
| Noorah chapter 1 . 1/3
That ended more painfully than I expected but was perfectly beautiful. Thank you.
| Guest chapter 1 . 4/10/2015
I first read this story back in 2011 on livejournal and I feel in love with it. It stuck with me. I recently read the poem "the hollow men" and all I could think about was this story, even tho I haven't thought about it since probably 2012. I may hate glee now but this fanfic, I still love, it made an impression. It's beautiful and perfect in every way. And I know for years to come I'll still be reminded of it everytime I hear that poem.
| cold kagome chapter 1 . 1/18/2014
aww pooor klaine p.p poor kurt so much in pain
| Guest chapter 1 . 1/11/2014
good story, could have been better if you wrote more... in regard to everything basically... their interactions, where was blaine staying? where was kurt in his life? how and when did they fall in love? why was blaine so fixated on the name while kurt was so ready to forget about it? a lot of things that i really needed to know while reading this but sadly was not included. loved how you described their emotions, so beautiful. you have a very nice way with words. last thing, i really need to say something about the rating, why is this fic rated m?
| ViolinMaroon chapter 1 . 7/26/2013
It's 4 (almost 5) in the morning and I'm crying like a bitch after reading this story...
Such a great story, yet so painful. Thank you for writing it :')
| Dr. Pepper 87 chapter 1 . 4/1/2013
... I don't know what to say. You have possibly played with every emotion I have ]
| pen 42 chapter 1 . 1/31/2013
That was by far the best soulmate story i have ever read. Understand that I almost never post reviews. The last review I posted was sometime last summer and was a long explanation of how to properly format a story. I hope you realize how much the story had to move me in order for me to comment on it. When i read the last line I just exhaled and sat still for a moment still, because it was so refreshing from everything else i have ever read. Amazing. Completely Amazing.
| lemon-rind chapter 1 . 9/29/2012
I love this story. The idea that you cant change things but desperately wish too, one of the best ways to get me all emotional.
| closetgleek chapter 1 . 9/18/2012
My heart. It's breaking and my eyes are leaking.
That was so beautiful. Your descriptions of scenery and their thoughts and their conversations. Everything. When Kurt breaks down, I just felt so heartbroken. I just... wow. "Wasn't it beautiful while it lasted?" I have a journal where I write quotes and things that I love. There are so many parts in this story that I want to write down and read over and over because they are so perfect. Then, at the same time, I want to just write this whole fic in that journal because, even though there are parts of it that are beautiful by itself, it's really the whole thing together that causes so many emotions. Love. Happiness. Dread. Heartbreak. The whole time reading it, I knew it couldn't end happy. I knew for it to be a really moving and wonderful story, it would end sad. But I still hoped.
I keep rereading the last few sections of the story. Kurt finds the post-it note. Blaine keeps the car. "This was never meant to be a love story." Not with a bang but with a whimper. And I feel like my heart breaks a little more every time I read through it.
This story is a reminder of the way words can be the most moving thing in the world.
| ForgotTheInfo chapter 1 . 9/14/2012
It would be a lie if I said I didn't check my hand for a name :P
I'm not sure if I love this or hate this one, really. It breaks my heart. But I know that this is life, and not everything ends beautifully, and this is so realistic.
I guess that's what makes this plot so heart-breaking. The reality in it.
Thank you for writing this. I don't know how or why, and I don't know why I've never realised it before but this tought me a big lesson. Thank you so much.
| ChrisColferLover14 chapter 1 . 8/6/2012
This. Is. Amazing. Omg made me cry!xxx
| piss-on-me-ally chapter 1 . 8/6/2012
Can you write an alternate ending, please...?
Oh well, this story is so amazing, it made me cry so much! I love you and hate you for this! but mostly love you. because this is amazing! :)
Now I'm going to listen to sad music and cry x
| Hardcore-nellie12-fan chapter 1 . 8/2/2012
Ohmy god the post it note are you fucking kidding me that was heart breaking! My creys! Sorry, if I wasn't on the phone I would've CAPed this!
I think I've had this story in my bookmarks for a year now.
| asweetmoonbeam chapter 1 . 7/27/2012
Ooh I hate sad endings, but this was so beautiful. Little bit confused on what happened to Quinn though?
| twistvine chapter 1 . 7/12/2012
i can't sleep, i'm crying so hard.
why is this so terribly good?