|Reviews for we cheer when stars fall|
| kingslayers chapter 1 . 1/5
hello madeline-alice how u been DELETE YOURSELF
but onto the pressing matter:
WAIT ARE YOU SERIOUS I HAVEN'T REVIEWED THIS WHAT
but I've talked to you about it? crying maybe I live blogged to you as I read it whatever
hi glorious so I know you don't even write hp anymore but this is still wonderful (I was stalking your profile for a particular fic when I saw this one and read it and looked for my review and couldn't find it jfc I'm the worst)
okay firstly LINING IS SILVER perfect good girl relient k triplet
um so I know you and lucysander aren't exactly friends but ! it was gorgeous and thank you for writing it for me, you precious munchkin xxxx
okay so what I like is that despite the absolutely heartbreaking premise, this is essentially a fluff fic. chockablock full of character development, don't get me wrong, but essentially feel good.
lorcan was actually my favorite because he was beautiful with his snarkiness and his lily (lilylorcan a plus) and his reasoning for dating Lucy and just ahsjdkdfld
did Jonathan get with Dominique? like for real I hope he did. also the resemblance of Lucy and molly was basically the perfect way to pull it all in. Nice surname for Audrey btw, very diverse compared to the normal hp ones.
UM SO LUCY AS AN ACTRESS AND LUCY PEVENSIE WERE JUST KIND OF GLORIOUS LIKE? your ideas are beautiful okay never stop with them
just wow I'm the worst and 10k lucylysander that is ridiculously glorious and thank you love you miss you lotsa xxxxxx
staplers ;) naomi-jane out
| over-rehearsed chapter 1 . 7/5/2012
Reviewing this for a review tag placeholder from way back when, and it won't be too god of a review as I'm doing a bunch of other fics as well BUT
Okay, so first of all I love all of your 10Ks they're always just so original and this was no exception. idk if i ever told you how much i adore your acting lucy? because i love just this whole plot was so so so original and lucysander and cute and i can't even just love okay love. :)
| nargleinfestedmistletoe chapter 1 . 10/22/2011
the plot is cliche, but the story is well written and cute:)
| Wandering Dawn chapter 1 . 9/24/2011
awah this isso unbelievably cute :) i love this lucy, she wasso innocent and alone it almost made me want to cry... which i did a little at the end haha
great story! :)
| renzhie chapter 1 . 8/5/2011
I haven't reviewed this? Gosh, I have such a bad memory! Anyway, I seriously love this Lucy/Lysander, Mad. I mean, I have to admit that I don't really have a thing against any pairing except Scorpius/Rose or Teddy/Victoire.
Your Lucy is just so brilliant and so is Lysander. I really love the storyline and this is one of my favourite 10ks.
And Lucy-Molly moment is just so sweet. )
Terrific job, Mad! )
| Melodiux chapter 1 . 5/30/2011
This is such a wonderful story!
| misswhiteblack chapter 1 . 5/25/2011
Oh my god, could this be anymore perfect? This was so wonderful and moving and incandescent in it's beauty. You wrote it so well and gave such life to the characters that they literally flew off the page and into reality. I adored it. Lucy was so sweet and wanting but had a charming composure about her fate. I thought Lysander was wonderful and charismatic. The bit at the end with Percy made me cry so much and I really enjoyed the character of Jonathon. This was an amazing fic and deserves so much praise. It was amazing and I loved it. Xxx
| verity candor chapter 1 . 5/24/2011
Anyway, lovey, YOUR LUCY IS THE SHIZZ.
First off - she is an orphan. That is something, I can honestly say, I have never. Never. seen. And it was awesome. I loved her as an actress, too - you really make it obvious why and how she's so wonderful at what she does. /i did think it was a bit cantrived that all her parts were things she was going through irl
BUT OMG LYSANDER. WAI MUST YOU BE SO CUUUUTE. AND HE TOTALLY WAAAAS. AND I KIND OF WANTED TO STEAL YOUR LORCAN, TOO, WHICH WAS JUST UNFAIR. GOD, WOMAN.
Anyway. I loved their romance, and how well you convey through just a few encounters - and, omg, the Molly/Lucy sistership - was just so sweet. I loved Molly's brilliantly done big sister character here - in fact, she was proooobably my favorite right after Lorcan.
Lovely job, dearie!
| a walk on the w i l d side chapter 1 . 5/24/2011
This was amazing, it really was. It was special and sweet and cute and wonderful. I love it, I really, really, absolutely do. It's fantastic, I love Lucy here.
I don't even particularly like Lucysander (LucyLorcan all the way) but I love this, I absolutely do. It's amazing, and the end (when maybe Jonathan will be her step-cousin and percy is crying and it's all really sad) was perfect. I love it, so so so much.
| stydias chapter 1 . 5/24/2011
Oh, darling, I'm in tears. This story, it's the meaning of perfection. One of your best yet. it. I can describe how much I love it.
Even though I'm a total LucyLysander freak, this has to be hands down one of my favorite stories ever.
Wonderful job, darling.
And I love you too 3
| BlueEyes444 chapter 1 . 5/24/2011
./staggers bckwards/ LUCYSANDER, MAD?
How dare you go to the dark site? D
This was just so flipping perfect. :D :D :D :D I loved every moment of it and it just had me grinning all day long. D
This is SUPER! :D
| tunystark chapter 1 . 5/23/2011
Mad, you're frickin' amazing.
This is freakin' amazing.
You could just feel every single word of it, and Lucy, oh Lucy...
I fell in love with her again and again.
Her acting, her way to escape things, her dreaminess...
it was beautiful...
he was just so perfect!
i this a million times over :)