|Reviews for Mad Maggie|
| hotshow chapter 2 . 6/6/2011
I thought this was a very good story.
Did you have any particular season in mind when you wrote it.
Looking forward to your next story.
| KKBELVIS chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
I could so live in a lighthouse!
Love all your research...especially about the phosphorescence cave! And Maggie thinking Sam was Giddion was an especially neat added touch.
Thank you for your hard work and tender care in creating a grand story for us to read.
| SunnyZim chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
What a treat to get another story from you so quickly! I absolutely loved this story - it kept me up way past my bedtime because it was so gripping! As always, I love the research that you put into your stories - it gives them a very authentic feel and I learn new things, which is always fun! I loved the fact that Maggie thought Sam was her husband - poor Sammy really does always attract the crazy ones (that perverted old lady in Red Sky at Morning comes to mind...) and I must admit I couldn't stop laughing at Dean's comments regarding giving Sam mouth to mouth - I must admit I cringed at his description of his unshaven face and his onion breath too! Great banter between the brothers as always and a truly well-written and entertaining story;-) Out of interest (I can't remember if I've asked you this before) but have you thought of writing original fiction? I think you'd be great at it;-)
| Jane88 chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
Great story, I ennjoyed this a lot!
"Two close calls even before the spirit shows up. That's some kind of record, even for us."
That's what I thought... so true. ;) Got another one:
"Relax. Lightning's gonna go after the tallest thing here." Dean... "Lucky for me, that would be you."
Had to laugh so hard. ;)
Like the lighthouse plot, there should be an episode with one. And I loved hurt Dean still doing everything he could to rescue Sam. Poor guy, shackled and almost drowning, that was so exciting. And I looked up the blue cave, really beautiful. Really great work, thanks so much!
| ncis-lady chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
Ah well, I guess I'm repeating myself here but: really great story! You just gotta love the boys when they take care of each other. I must say that I missed that during the last season (which is why I'm currently re-watching season 2 ;)).
Thanks for the a/n. Very good job on the research, it's kinda cool to know that the story's based on an actual myth. (One more reason why the story would make a damn good episode on the show)
| Colby's girl chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
Woohoo! That was fun and intense. I'm happy you posted it all and I was able to read it in it's entirety. So pleased to read one of your fabulous stories. Cheers!
PS I googled the light house while reading the beginning so I had a great visual while reading.
| Rosetta Brunestud chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
WOW! Great story! )
I really enjoyed it, dear! Very well-written, full of details! Nice plot too, really good stuff! LOL
I like this one, very much
| ncis-lady chapter 1 . 6/5/2011
Ah you're a star! Great story so far, love it! I can totally imagine that being an actual episode because it's got everything I love about the show.
Is there a way to purchase the Blood Brothers fanzine? I just googled it and found some info (which sounds fab) but couldn't find a way to order it.
| vonnie836 chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
Wow again, this was sure a difficult hunt. I knew Dean would wake up before Sam returned and it was good he did, as Sam needed him. He sure outdid himself, working through all his injuries and giving his all to find his brother. Poor Sam, he just can't win. All shackled up, in rising water, almost drowning and freezing to death, what a double whammy. Dean really cut it close, but he did it. But it shows just how bad Sam was that he didn't remember a lot about the hospital stay. In the end though it was due to his knowledge and Dean's persistence that both of them made it. I call that teamwork. Great job with this story, now I just hope there will be more from you soon. Hugs, Vonnie
| carocali chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
I so enjoy your stories! This had great detail and research and an equal helping of h/c for both the boys! The brotherly banter was perfect, as always, and it had me hanging on from start to finish!
Thanks so much for posting! More please!
| vonnie836 chapter 1 . 6/5/2011
Wow, this is creepy. I always loved the atmosphere of lighthouses in storms, really eerie and scary. Put a ghost in it and it really freaks me out. Love it! The boys certainly have their hands full and Maggie thinking Sam is Gideon and targeting Dean for it, wow that is so not good. Gotta read on now! Hugs, Vonnie
| Maz101 chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
What a great - old-style - Winchester adventure. Loved how you got straight into it with the near-death trip to the lighthouse, only then going back to tell the background to them taking the hunt - very effective for grabbing the attention! I do love mutual hurt/comfort and this was great for that - very pacey with no let up.
It comes as such a nice change to have a straight forward, no angels, no demons, no deals, no arcs story. So, thanks for a great read.
| SimplyOut chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
Awesome story. The setting was great, the plot was nicely done and the boys were just lovable. I wanna actually see the boys do a hunt like this in a lighthouse with a crappy rope bridge and everything in an episode :D
| gapdragon1 chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
Highly enjoyable - excellent plot, dialogue and characterisation. Loved the history behind the story. Thank you
| Rachelly chapter 2 . 6/5/2011
This was AWESOME! I loved every word! The brothers were in perfect form- snarky, humorous, totally concerned for each other's safety and willing to do anything to help each other. Your story had so many turns...Sam's in trouble on the bridge then Dean, Sam is picked by Maggie and Dean is attacked as her enemy for wanting to have Sam leave with him, and Sam gets shackled in a cave with an incoming tide! WOW! I love protective Dean, even when hurt, he'll do anything for Sam. Excellent piece. So nice to read the brothers together hunting things that aren't angel and demon related. A good ole fashioned MOTW! Perfect! Thanks for all you put into this!~RAchelly