|Reviews for Elsewhere, but not Elsewhen|
| Darklooshkin chapter 23 . 6/3/2012
I think that the Hallows fall under the general category of 'things you should never deploy in battle'. That, and wands, but I digress. Maybe having someone other than Harry or Rachel become Master/Mistress of Death instead?
| scorpioneldar chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
very interesting please continue
| scorpioneldar chapter 21 . 6/2/2012
ohh foolish male mortal what sanity :D that is all
| scorpioneldar chapter 19 . 6/2/2012
personaly im not so sure it would be that simple for either side
in the end i think muggles would win but then im biased
remember to wizards have had people forging muggle paperwork for quite some time just to prevent them from being caught out by unexplained holes in the records that is in cannon though i wouldn't be surprised if that was some muggleborn in a basement at the ministry
there would be much internal fighting over whether or not we should go to war how to handle it, wat to consider wizard )are they all enemy combatants or only some who and why?) though in a voldemort run wizarding world there would then be a terorist leader and we all know how britan and the united states feels about terrorism that may actualy simplify it quite a bit for us...
hmm not sure
also im not the reviewer you were mentioning just someone else interested in the debate also consider that in the united states at least(it's where i live so i acctualy know something about this) only roughly 1 perccent of the population is involved in the armed forces and only 3 and a half have family or friends in the armed fores so no wizards would only have to kill so many military men with an unblockable attack and escape using what would be called teleportation before you start running out of armed and combat ready people and with apparation and silencing spells not to mention invisibility one wizard could kill a quarter of a sleeping barracks before being caught and killed maybe even the whole room
again once we figure out what is going on we could counter such tactics off the top of my head use a device that scans for gaps inthe air or detects presence by displacment of it and tie it into an alarm if more people are present than there are supposed to be it goes off
it would be a race can we counter enough effective tactics and hit enough important locations and people in the magical world before they get everyone rallied together against the "barbaric muggles" as every housewife and child age 14 and up can hit you with a spell that causes you to explode and thus can in a pinch fight against you while a good prtion of america may not even get up off the couch except to protest the war God knows enough of them protest our hunting muslim extremist through the desert after 3 attempts to take down the twin towers (that i know of) the last of which succeeded an attempt on the white house successful attacks on the pentagon attempts to build a Muslim symbol of conquest on ground zero and multiple terrorist attacks daily that are stopped by the work of our armed forces. i know this because my father was involved in some of these operations and handled some of the intelligence involved needless to say i think our will to fight is not what it used to be but then i am the disgruntled and somewhat dis ilusioned son of a Captian in the navy
anyway back on track i love your story and would love to see more as to who wins i guess it is a question of who gets motivated enough to get off their asses first cause the other side will find tactical strikes occurring in their living rooms before they get the chance to realize that sitting around was a stupid idea
either special forces on decapitation or capture strikes or wizards useing apperation and killing curses
though our penchant for saturation bombardment does give us the upper hand for killing large groups at once and maybe Britain would be less devided about killing the terrorists in their mists(notsure how to spell that) though im not to sure about that
please write more and may i say i enjoy your Mr Tom convenient middle name Riddle
| tenchifew chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
Very informative chapter.
Looking forward to see just what will be going on in Hogwarts.
Hermione is, as usual, amazing.
Thank you for writing.
| Smithback chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
I love Hermione beeing so clever
| Ibskib chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
Wasn't Harry's explanation to Rachel for the name Rex already done two chapters back?
| Archmagelite2000yrs chapter 19 . 6/2/2012
until some dark magic specialist came up with a plague? magically enhanced rabies anyone?
| alichi chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
They don't want 'Bitch' in the title? I'm actually close to unloading my frustration at the wall 'cause of that kind of absurd censorship...
Ask if 'female dog' would be acceptable to the sensibles of the honored admin...
And then ask said admin why they are only harassing you and not the 32 other fics with 'bitch' in the summary or title.
Hope you get an apology and put the real name on the fic again.
| Raj8 chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
Interesting chapter as always.
| jbfritz chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
| Still Not Dead Yet chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
I look forward to reading more about that proposal.
I'm surprised they destroyed the Horcrux, then again presumably Dumbledore destroyed the diary so only the snake would remain; I guess I shouldn't be surprised.
As always I look forward to your next update!
| JEr chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
Great chapter. Is James going to keep the hallow?
As for Jamie Evans... that's a dumb reason for taking it down. Still love the fic though.
| S058 chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
Yeah, one of my fav fics, Reunions Are A Bitch got taken down because of that BS notice.
I take it you dislike all those POS HP romance fics with "Soul bonds"? Good, so do I. It's a crappy plot device at best, at worst, it's downright pathetic.
| Wulffe chapter 23 . 6/2/2012
Another good chapter ..thank you ..