Reviews for I could have
scgaraycochea chapter 1 . 9/6/2014
Very nice. This is something mising in the book.
I really enjoyed this.
Thank you for give us othe view point of this amazing story.
CersiFinallyGotWhatSheDeserved chapter 1 . 9/3/2012
Very moving.
MyLovelyRAB chapter 1 . 11/5/2011
Fantastic! Id love to know what Harry found inside the homes and if he ended up living there.
Miso Muchi chapter 1 . 9/1/2011
It isn't favorable, but it is memorable. The writing of Snape lacked his silky quality, if that makes sense.
David boreanaz's wife247 chapter 1 . 8/29/2011
wonderful
BelieveInTheHoundsOfJustice60 chapter 1 . 8/10/2011
One of the best fanfiction stories ever.
Edwina B. Karch chapter 1 . 8/7/2011
Great story I enjoyed it. The final words were fitting. Well done. Thanks for the journey
lilyann78 chapter 1 . 7/30/2011
Great story indeed! Thank you for sharing!
Coriandergirl chapter 1 . 7/24/2011
i just (finally!) saw the movie tonight, and i wanted to tell you that, if not for the fact that i completely bawled myself out earlier( i was going pretty strong from the beginning), i would definitely be crying right now. this is a very touching, sad, haunting, beautiful story. you have a couple reoccurring typos or what have you, but the actual story is perfect-i so wish severus could have raised harry... things could have ended up so differently. in any event, thank you for this story.
blossoming art chapter 1 . 7/23/2011
As much as I enjoyed reading this, I feel like it is quite a bit more far-fetched than I was expecting. The whole point of the Pensieve memories, in the book and in the movie, was that Snape never did learn to care for Harry. When Dumbledore asks him if he has after expressing concern for Harry being a 'pig for slaughter', he conjures his doe Patronus. Dumbledore asks him if he still loves Lily after all this time, and he says 'Always'. It is Lily that he has and always will love, not Harry. I know it's fan fiction, but I do believe in believability and credibility. I felt like there needed to be more build-up to something so big. Especially since it seemed as though in Snape's journal, he hinted that he wanted to take Harry in to protect him. That would NEVER have happened, sorry to say. Again, I realize it is fan fiction, but once again, it's got to be a bit more believable. And perhaps proofread a bit more thoroughly. You've got quite a few mistakes, date-wise and in terms of your spelling/grammar.
UnderdogAngel chapter 1 . 7/23/2011
Wow, Alisha! I really really like this . I was moved to tears (especially when Harry saw Molly shaking over the sink of dishes). Beautifully done, my friend. I do indeed believe that Snape grew to love Harry as more than just "Lilly's son". *cries* We really gotta go see DHp2 again, seriously. Great job on this, my friend! :D
The Light from Within chapter 1 . 7/22/2011
You've got the basic essence of Snape's feelings and background, towards Harry. You've got all of it most correctly. As time went on, you can see, in Snape, that there was 'something' in him that liked or 'sided' with Harry. Good job at writing all of his feelings. You're a good writer. Keep up the good work, please. Tom