|Reviews for A Soul, A Mentality, A Name|
| TheMightyE chapter 15 . 3/7
| Mischel chapter 15 . 2/12
OMG! I can't write how incredibly much I love this fanfic! :D I enjoyed it all so so much! I love the part when Arthur is questioning Merlin-Dragoon about his magic and everything, and I love their party in the end. It was so amazing work that I almost couldn't breathe in some parts. I was so sad that the Gvarath stole the auras from knights, and I was afraid that they won't survive and then I had to go to sleep. Can you imagine how terrible it was to be in school almost the whole next day without the chance to read more? Really terrible! When I finally got home I immediately started to read again and the last 10 chapters (or so) I read in one breath. So what can I write you in the end of this review? WELL DONE! :D :D :D
| Grank chapter 15 . 2/11
I swear that this story is good enough to be cannon although I don't think I want to know what that thing would look like as a picture
amazing story and you used dragoon who seems under used in most stories
| ProcrastinationIsMyCrime chapter 2 . 2/8
Loved the banter. Merlin certainly was mouthy
| wryter501 chapter 15 . 2/7
you know, this was missing from the series also... no one found out, no one told stories, no one thanked him, no one celebrated... just arthur, for two dying days... and then ,as far as we're told, merlin hangs out on the bank of the lake for a century and a half, some kind of miserable hermit... damn them. and - thank you! :)
| wryter501 chapter 14 . 2/7
i LOVE that arthur unconsciously figured out that dragoon was merlin, in the middle of facing gvarath...
i find myself thinking of the ending of you've got mail - when meg ryan has fallen in love with tom hanks' character as well as his email personality - and she meets him and realizes, and says, i hoped it was you etc. seems to me like arthur's made a connection with 'dragoon' and subconsciously hopes that it's merlin
ps - how come no one ever recognizes that dragoon is wearing merlin's BOOTS?!
| wryter501 chapter 11 . 2/7
i like you you write dragoon - it's very close to the way he was played in the series. if i can hear a character saying their lines in their voice in my head as i'm reading... that means you've caught the character very well!
| wryter501 chapter 10 . 2/7
i like gwen knowing, it feels true to the series. she was right on the verge, the lamia episode - i was so disappointed they didn't go there. doesn't feel like gwen would just forget to make merlin explain... and then she pretty much guessed, the last episode...
| wryter501 chapter 9 . 2/7
i like dragoon also, but the problem is his age... at heart, merlin is young and energetic enough to get in the middle of a fight, but dragoon... i'm a little worried...
| wryter501 chapter 6 . 2/7
i like how the healing spell uses merlin's skills as a physician also - it's a good explanation for why he's pretty poor at it in the beginning, and gets better... :)
| wryter501 chapter 5 . 2/7
i loved the percival reveal! perfect, that it felt like coming home for him as well, after living with the druids... and omg the campfire fight scene!
| StarOfTheSeaa chapter 15 . 2/1
Oh my god. All I can say is, wow! That was axing! I'm so glad Arthur finally knows, and not just that accepts Merlin for who he is! I have just started rewatching Merlin on Netflix (I've already seen all the episodes when the originally aired) and all I can say, is when I was feeling frustrated with the show I would turn to your story to lift my spirits. This is what should have happened! Your writing is amazing and I could see everything happening before my eyes. You did an excellent job of capturing the characters and portraying them. You are wonderful! This story is one of the best, I have read in a long time.
So thank you.
Thank you for this treat in a life of disappointments. You should be proud.
You deserve an award for this.
| Auua Ytjoml chapter 13 . 1/22
Did Merlin's/Dragoon's fear give it away to Arthur?
| mersan123 chapter 14 . 1/2
This is the first time I have read this fic of yours. Just wanted to pass on my congrats on a truly brilliant piece of writing. It was entertaining, humorous, angsty and all round just a great read. I loved how you treated each and every character and in the end the reveal its self.
I am now moving on to read Bk2 and really looking forward to it!
Many, many thanks. I will definitely read this one again!
Best wishes (and a happy new year).
| RiddleWrappedInAnEnigma chapter 15 . 12/28/2013
I would have liked a few more details on how everyone reacted to hearing Merlin's story, but other than that, it was great!