Just rereading this wonderful monster of a fic for about the third time. I do love how the marauders are here. It's just how I'd expect their early years at hogwarts to be.

Rereading this has become something of a holiday tradition for me- your work has a special place in my heart. I read this for the first time back in seventh grade, and now I'm in my second year at university! Few things have stayed with me that long, and I treasure those that have. Of course I hope for an update to our favorite troublemakers' adventures, but more importantly I hope that all is well with you! Merry Christmas!

DORCAS, I also loved Dorcas and how you differentiated from other fanfics as Dorcas is usually in the marauders’ year. There’s honestly so much more I wanted to comment on. OOOOH and Remus transformations and how you dealt with that was amazinggg, not to mention andromeda and her storyline, which I really thing you brought to life where most fanfic writers just add in

Holy crap. I honestly have no words . This is genuinely one of THE BEST Harry Potter fanfic or fanfic is General I’ve ever read. I LOVE how you dealt with the characters and their characterisation and how they all had they own storyline’s. I love all your OCs (Betta MacFusty was pretty cool) and the Defense teachers were amazing. I also really liked how you dealt with the whole war thing and how death eaters came to be. KASKKSKDJKSKWS I JUST LOVE EVERYTHING ABKU THIS. Will definitely reread this and forever hope you’ll update :)

Hello. I don’t usually review on stories that haven’t updated in so long, but I saw that some of your other stories have been updated more recently and that gives me some small hope that maybe you’ll return to this story some day. Regardless, I wanted to thank you for sharing this wonderful story with us. This is by far the best Harry Potter fanfic I’ve ever read and I hope that you’ll continue to write. You’re truly an amazing author. Your attention to detail and the complexity of your characters is incredible and I loved every chapter of this story.

Still one of my favorite re-reads and fanfics of all time. Thank you so much for giving it to us.

This is an amazing fanfiction. Your writing is consistently at a very high level and I must say I am impressed at your ability to create essentially a day by day life story for the marauders for 3 years of their life and I am sure you have plenty more planned for them in your head. I really hope that you do come back to this story and I really look forward to any updates if you decide to do so

I read this story once four years ago and it always stuck with me and now I'm back for a second time hehe 3 this story is honestly so beautiful and the characterization is flawless, it so perfectly captures the spirit of the books and also is such a well thought out, emotive and exciting story! Amazing, 100/10, thank you so much for this _

Wonderful story, thank you for writing it! I love how you've characterised all the Maruaders and how perfectly it fits with canon.

To everyone: all right, why does no one want to edit/contribute to the TvTropes page? I have been dropping hints left and right, and I am done. If you truly loved this story, you would contribute to the page en masse, so I guess you don't like as much.

Finished up my fifth (sixth? tenth? lost track) reread of this fic. I've been following it and your other works for so many years, and they remain as wonderful as ever each time I come back to them. I don't think I've ever had writing resonate with me the way this fic does. I guess what I'm trying to say is... thank you. I'm indescribably grateful for the time and energy and love you put into your work. Wherever you are, whatever you're doing, I hope you are happy, healthy, and inspired.

And I made a TvTropes page for this after all: /Fanfic/AgainstTheMoon

I invite everyone who wishes to and has time to add whatever they feel like belongs there.

I love this fanfiction and this is the third time I've read it! I realy hope you're doing better and if you ever feel like it, please update! I love this so so much and I haven't done any homework because of it!

Someone should really make a TvTropes page for this story. It deserves to have one.

Would do it myself, but I am horrible with naming the appropriate Tropes.

Your presentation is high-quality but I dislike the tonal implications of this chapter. I may continue later.

Also, since I am not overly a HP fan and new to fanfiction, I don't know much background. If Remus' mum truly felt alienated by being a Muggle why did she wed a wizard?

Plus, due to personal experience, I don't buy the too oft presented 'women are more empathetic than males' that so many claim and you imply here.

Your skill is clear but I come atv things from a different place than likely most of your readers.

I sincerely hope your trials are easing and that you complete this if you desire to. I have several conditions myself so I get that at times stress, pain, and lack of focus/energy can hamper ability to write.

So too, that writing can be a solace like nothing else when the words sing.

May you be well. :)