|Reviews for Day of the Black Sun|
| Jake Anthony chapter 10 . 12/9/2019
You gotta make a story based on all 5 movies with firestorm in it
| Marcus S. Lazarus chapter 27 . 12/31/2017
A dramatic opening that led into a very well-written story.
Once I get past my distaste for Carly as a character- I get that there were real-world reasons for Mikaela’s absence, but they could have found a better way to compensate for that- it’s slightly amusing to see the ‘family dynamic’ she’s formed with Sam and their Autobot houseguests, even without the new presence of the Sparklings into the bargain.
Each development in your plot is well-handled without anything appearing forced or making certain characters appear incompetent or over-powered, ranging from Blaster’s temporary capture to Scattershot’s defection, to say nothing of the revelation of Firestorm’s true agenda in choosing a side so many millennia ago.
Of course, I particularly prefer your take on Unicron to the film’s canon; the new take on him might be intriguing but it feels unnecessarily complicated, as though they’re trying too hard to reinforce the idea that Earth and Cybertron are connected when the simple presence of the Allspark should have clarified those issues well enough all on its own from the first film onwards.
Still, with Galvatron’s ever-degenerating mental state to take into account, as well as other Decepticons having their own agenda even if they aren’t willing to acknowledge that their leader’s latest rebirth has left him several circuits short, I hope you haven’t abandoned this story; it has FAR too much potential to leave us perpetually hanging with so many potential threats to overcome.
| Guest chapter 27 . 9/5/2017
Hi! I just wanted you to know that I am a new reader of your story, and I absolutely love it!
| AutobotGuy710 chapter 2 . 7/18/2017
I have to finish this later but WOW this is amazing so far. I applaud how well you've written this so far. And I can't wait to read more of it. I just have to go to work sadly. :( expect more reviews from me though!
| Wacko12 chapter 27 . 7/18/2017
what about the AOE and TLK Aubotos? Also can you add Cliffjumper and Warpath?
| Marcus S. Lazarus chapter 26 . 4/17/2015
VERY nice bit of work, to say the least.
If nothing else, I liked the fact that you kept the original human allies in; ‘Age of Extinction’ was certainly dramatic, and the new efforts to hunt the Autobots could be ‘understood’ to an extent (Once you assume that the Autobots’ old government contacts are being manipulated and kept ignorant of what’s really happening to them), but I just wish they’d included at least a couple of lines about what happened to Sam, NEST, and everyone else.
With your storyline keeping the ‘original’ cast intact, it’s fascinating to see how things develop after Firestorm’s arrival, the team all having learned how to avoid repeating the mistakes that allowed Sentinel to mount such a devastating assault in his time on Earth even if Firestorm quickly manages to provide evidence that he’s not just another Decepticon.
Subsequent events as the Autobots attempt to rally their resources against both threats are definitely handled well, giving Optimus a good opportunity to get some actual flight training rather than just zooming around and shooting at things from above, while the wider combat details provide an interesting contrast with the more personal touches such as the revelation of Chromia’s imminent fate.
Galvatron’s creation and his immediate actions also perfectly fit Megatron’s character; he seemed fairly loyal to the Fallen, but since the evidence suggests that the Fallen was in charge from the beginning that was only natural, whereas he would definitely resent Unicron’s ‘assumption’ of authority despite whatever he might ‘owe’ the Devourer. Even his self-aborted ‘deal’ made sense; he might hate Unicron, but he’d never be able to get past his own arrogance and need for control to accept the necessity of collaborating with Optimus if he saw an opportunity for ‘vengeance’ (The fact that he’s becoming increasingly unstable only makes it more apparent).
Oh, and the Sparklings make a nice touch as well; a part of me would like to see a bit more of them interacting with the humans- and on the topic of kids, it could be amusing to see Lennox’s daughter interact with them- but you develop the characters very well, finding the right balance between making them children and making them interesting characters with a touchingly innocent perspective on everything around them.
Hope you keep up the great work; I am DEFINITELY looking forward to seeing what happens when the final clash with Unicron takes place…
| Wacko12 chapter 26 . 3/28/2015
are you going to bring Hound, Drift, Crosshair and the Dinobots in? The Autobots could use some back up
| Wacko12 chapter 25 . 7/11/2014
are you going to add the Autobots from AOE?
| Agent ERA chapter 24 . 7/7/2014
A very intriguing story...now, I know this is mainly about the Autobots but could perhaps we see a little more of Will?(and maybe just a teensy liitle bit of hurt!Will?). Just curious...
| Wacko12 chapter 24 . 4/5/2014
there should be more Autobots like Hound, Crosshair and Wingblade. Maybe Dinobots and where is Mirage?
| Wacko12 chapter 22 . 11/7/2013
so is he going to be called Gavaltron now? and will the Autobots get more comrades? hopefully bulky ones like Crosshair, Armorhide, Warpath or even Wingblade.
| ZabuzasGirl chapter 1 . 9/21/2013
Update immediately, please!
| Jessica Wolfe chapter 3 . 9/20/2013
There's a quick POV shift from Cyclonus to the gathered Decepticons in the scene before the meeting at the Pinnacle. You could fix this by having Cyclonus overhear the other Decepticons talking, rather than making it seem like thoughts from the others.
I really like how you're keeping most of the plan a secret, but having other characters grumble about it. The Decepticons are voicing the reader's feelings about not knowing the plan, so in a way, that makes the reader feel better about not knowing. And then you give the reader a morsel at the end by filling Salvo-and therefor the reader-in on a bit more of the plan. Good tension building. Well done. :)
| Jessica Wolfe chapter 2 . 9/16/2013
Suggested rework for clarity: A startled squeak emerged from the Sparkling he lifted from under the bed and into his arms. [This is in Sam's POV so he can just identify what he's pulling out from under the bed.]
LOL. The thought of Blaster pouting is hilarious to me. :)
Suggested rework for clarity: Sam tucked the little Sparkling under one arm, earning another squeak from Blaster, but with the iPod distracting him he was too preoccupied to wriggle much. It was really lucky that Blaster-the smallest of the Sparklings, at only a little bit smaller than Wheelie and Brains-was the one living with them. Sam knew that he wouldn't have been able to carry any of the others like this.
He grabbed one of the smaller packed boxes and held it under his free arm as he [exited] the room and headed for the stairs.
"Yeah. He was hiding under the bed, trying to listen to my iPod[." Sam shook] his head.
There're two places in the Sam/Bee scene where you mention "the box he had brought downstairs". You can probably drop one or both of these references, since I think the reader will assume that Sam is still holding the box until you have him set it down.
There's a lot of reiterating information in this chapter that we already know. You can drop a lot of it to keep the action moving along.
There's some POV shifting within the chapter. I don't know if you're aware of doing it or not. I'd suggest you try to stay in one character's head as much as possible, and if you have to shift to another head, make a clear transition from one POV to another.
| Jessica Wolfe chapter 1 . 9/16/2013
Great first chapter. I like the way you're building tension by giving us some information about this new enemy, but leaving room for more surprises.
Here's some suggestions I had to clear up a few sentences. Anything between the [ ] are my suggestions, except for the second sentence, which I just “fixed”. ;)
It was too far away, but the aura it gave off[-]cold and violent, evil and unforgiving, like a huge black shadow that sucked the energy out of everything it touched[-]was something he was cursed to feel even here.
Suggested rework for clarity: The approaching threat was very real, but it had long ago faded into myth; into legends that were rarely spoken of, let alone believed, by most Cybertronians alive today.
But it would certainly give them a fighting chance, which was something they did not have[-]that they would never have[-]if he didn't get there in time.
On to the next! :D