Reviews for Forged in Flames |
---|
Ralina chapter 1 . 11/30/2019 An interesting beginning. I am curious how you will continue the story... |
Ninushka chapter 24 . 11/25/2019 While I kind of like this story for being quite well written, I also hate it for glorifying an abusive relationship like this... Snape in this story is the ultimate asshole and Hermione is the kicked puppy who loves him regardless and keeps coming back for more. It's absolutely unhealthy and toxic and it kind of makes me sad. Well done for a quite original backstory and decent grammar though. |
Faeforever chapter 29 . 10/13/2019 I loved this story. Thanks for writing it |
Guest chapter 29 . 9/18/2019 Excellent story. I hope you have great success. Don't try to publish on your own without a Beta reader. A Beta reader would have been able to fix the plot holes. Toward the end, I kept wondering why they kept acting like idiots. Kissing in a public hallway, arguing in public after the dance. Arguing in the library. And her stupidity of going all over by herself was moronic. When she got kidnapped, nobody looked at Harry's map to find her. Melvin was underused. Snape never took advantage of the rooftop exit provided by the Room of Requirement, even though Bella used it easy enough. |
Guest chapter 21 . 9/18/2019 Hahaha. I laugh at Draco's pain. NO SYMPATHY FOR HIM AT ALL IN THIS STORY. And as usual, I hate Albus. |
Guest chapter 19 . 9/18/2019 Nobody thought to steal Harry's map. Oh-oh! |
Guest chapter 16 . 9/18/2019 Confused heroes. Don't go anywhere alone vs come to me tomorrow night, alone. |
Guest chapter 11 . 9/17/2019 Intense |
Guest chapter 9 . 9/17/2019 Rotflmao |
Guest chapter 6 . 9/17/2019 Good, good, good. |
Guest chapter 4 . 9/17/2019 Oho! |
Guest chapter 2 . 9/17/2019 Exciting stuff. Intriguing. Great beginning, with me coming up with all sorts of possible suspects sand plot ideas. |
maple420leaf chapter 29 . 8/26/2019 make a sequel lol |
clarine chapter 29 . 8/17/2019 Excellente histoire et rondement menée, avec suspens et émotion. Malgré cela, j'ai trouvé Severus un peu dense dans sa relation avec Hermione, alors que, même s'il est évidemment mal à l'aise et maladroit dans l'interaction sociale, j'attendais un peu plus de subtilité de la part d'un espion habitué à jouer double et à maîtriser ses émotions. En fait, c'est Hermione qui gère cela de la manière la plus adulte, alors qu'elle aurait mille fois plus de raison d'être traumatisée. Bref, je la trouve pour sa part un peu trop compréhensive face aux égarements de Snape et d'une manière générale, ce renversement de situation (à savoir que c'est elle l'adulte dans la relation) affaiblit un peu l'histoire. Mais cela reste relativement mineur comme critique car cela ne m'a pas empêchée de lire votre histoire d'une traite, impatiente d'en connaître le dénouement. Merci. |
alannalove1990 chapter 29 . 7/24/2019 Very good |