|Reviews for Regrets|
| amgonyea chapter 1 . 8/29/2016
That's pretty much how I expected it to happen on the show.
| Delete-account-please-6878249 chapter 1 . 7/3/2015
Very good it was really cute.
| Delete-account-please-6829121 chapter 1 . 7/3/2015
Cute story I enjoy it.
| delete-account-please-6358491 chapter 1 . 2/11/2015
glad to have located this story. It really was amazing.
| delete-account-please-6354030 chapter 1 . 2/10/2015
i’m so glad to have picked this story. It really was unthinkable.
| onewaywardgirl chapter 1 . 4/10/2013
| Bekah chapter 1 . 2/22/2013
Ive read this one-shot quite a few times now and I know your busy with 'Someone To Love You' but I really think this has potential to become a multi-chapter and I would LOVE it if you tried writing it :)
| Bekah chapter 1 . 2/22/2013
Ive read this one-shot quite a few times and I know your busy with 'Someone To Love You' but I really think this has amazing potential to be a multi-chapter and I would LOVE it if you tried writing it :)
| ChordOverstreetFan chapter 1 . 11/8/2012
This was a great fix for that episode. The episode wouldn't have needed a fix, though, if RIB was smart and kept Finchel apart! Finn has never seemed comfortable in his own skin, and you just shouldn't be intimate like that without being comfortable with your body. So I'm not surprised it was awkward.
I still think that the fact she lost her virginity to Finn, in canon, is the ONLY reason she agreed to his proposal. I stand by the idea that would have said NO if Jesse showed her something better before his proposal - but, no, they always keep Jesse away until sometime after sectionals or regionals.
| TeebsSingerWriter chapter 1 . 9/1/2012
"Do you wanna grab a burger?" Ha, I'm sure the writers would have found a way to use that in the actual episode in order to show how inexperienced but caring Finn is and how much he loves Rachel. Thanks for making "The First Time" bearable for me and lots of other StBerry shippers, too.
| LookingAnswers chapter 1 . 8/5/2012
Ohhh I wish that was the real episode
| writingrox12 chapter 1 . 5/16/2012
This. Was. Perfect. Seriously. I was looking for something wonderful and St. Berry to read after watching Nationals, and I found it. God, I love the idea of her regularly cheating on Finn with Jesse just a little too much. No shame.
I'd love to see more of this if it ever strikes your fancy to continue it. :)
| Sea Serpent chapter 1 . 12/25/2011
I thought Finn's question was very in character (and I'm guessing he'd get her one with real meat if she'd said yes). Although I prefer to think that Rachel simply gave Finn a lock of her hair and then went home, I liked this version of what happened afterwards.
| Cris chapter 1 . 11/21/2011
Okay, finally getting a free minute to start on my backlog of reviews! I laughed out loud at the first sentence of this one, because I knew IMMEDIATELY what Finn was referencing before he even said anything. Talk about insensitive! And yet somewhat understandable, too, because it’s his only experience to go off of. Hardly the scientific method, but then, we ARE talking about Finn here. I thought it was a nice parallel to the actual episode (which I know you hadn’t watched when you wrote this) that he asked if she wanted to grab a burger, and he ended up feeding her meat in the episode. Either way, it’s a pretty clear indicator that he doesn’t really know her well at all.
I STILL don’t know what possessed Rachel to do such a thing, but I suppose it’s in canon now and we might as well make the best of it. Or put our fingers in our ears, as erinsgirl has done. Check out this great quote: “I believe season 3 doesn't actually exist and season 2's existence is pretty questionable.” If only…
Poor girl, I felt really bad for her here when all was said and done and she realized that her first time was nothing worth remembering. Well, I take that back. It’s worth remembering so she doesn’t make the same mistake again: worth remembering that Finn isn’t all she made him out to be.
Well, at least this once Finn’s perpetual inattention was all for the good, because it got him out of the house without an argument. She’s going to have to deal with this at some point – cut him loose or accept that he’s as inept physically as he is at just about everything else – but I’m kind of glad we didn’t see the showdown here in this story. Without it, the story is more about her and Jesse coming together and re-forming their connection than it is about her growing away from Finn.
“Even through the fog of her pain, it occurred to her that Finn had seemed incredibly uncomfortable. Almost as if his hormones had driven him to perform an act that his mind wasn't quite ready to accept.” I LOVE this! It rings with authenticity. This is SO Finn! He’s uncomfortable in his own skin, so of course he’d be uncomfortable performing an intensely personal and physical act. It’s not something he’s comfortable with, and furthermore, it’s not something he’s comfortable with wanting. With Santana it was probably ten times easier, too – she knew what she was doing, she took control, and he just kind of had to be her puppet. But the dynamic is different here, and he wasn’t ready for it, and he didn’t handle it well at all. The fact that Rachel is able, even in her own moment of upset, to acknowledge how uncomfortable he seemed says a lot for her character. Finn no doubt noticed nothing of the kind about her.
But going back to Jesse, it was SO like him to just show up in her room like that, without warning. I love his devious side! Rachel’s automatic defense of Finn, while understandable, is awfully hard to sit through for those of us who know the truth she’s not yet ready to admit – that Finn isn’t and can never be what she wants or needs. Especially when she has to lie so badly in order to defend him. Thankfully, she’s a terrible liar and Jesse can see through it anyway, pressing her until she has no excuses left.
And when her second time was over (INFINITELY better than the first!) Jesse stayed with her, curling up with her and holding her like she (sort of) wanted from Finn but he wouldn’t provide. There really isn’t a comparison between the two encounters. Jesse is at home in his body the way Finn isn’t; he’s infinitely more experienced, but it’s more than that. It’s the way he feels about her, and how he knows her so well, and wants her happiness as much as his own.
TOO FUNNY that Finn doesn’t like the way she smells the next morning! Because of course she smells like Jesse, but he doesn’t know it (unless it’s some subconscious memory that he doesn’t recognize). And poor Finn doesn’t realize how much she was turned off by him, and her plans to use her dads as a convenient cockblocking excuse in the future. Or that she’s calling Jesse in her spare time…
Fantastic fix (as I knew it would be), and I can’t thank you enough for giving me something else to think about when I watched the episode. Because I’m a masochist and of course I watched it. Thank you for this alternate reality!
| hayley30 chapter 1 . 11/18/2011
Wow, this was just perfect. In the beginning I was actually getting disgusted by how horrible Finn was to her. The way you described how Rachel was feeling, was just ugh. No words. Pure Torture. And then! So beautifully contrasted with Jesse! He is so perfect!
This was the perfect way to fix the atrocity of "The First Time"; well the episode wasn't all together too bad, but the Finchel definitely was.
Perfect, perfect, perfect!