|Reviews for The Fifth-Grade Grinch|
| Vi-Violence chapter 1 . 2/27/2013
Impressive, I wish Cas was in it though.
| Guest chapter 1 . 10/31/2012
YES. This is what happened, regardless of what the TV says. Beautiful and wonderful and abso-bloody-lutely splendid. Well done :)
| AvenaCookie chapter 1 . 8/21/2012
I was brought here by xxxcmfxxx and just spent this hour just loving this. For real, tears... tears! FutureDean was amazing! Gosh he was awesome with littleSam and when he had that dream yelling for Cas.. that short sentence made me wonder what had happened! (Cas fan..).. and dean going back to change it... finally a great ending! Like the 9th doctor says - everybody lives!
But really, just so well done! Loved every bit! I went back to read it and cried again. Any piece that has little sammy crying makes me start as well. And gabriel! Omg he's part of all this too! Hehehe perfect story!
| criminalxxxmindsxxxfreak chapter 1 . 8/20/2012
Dude this story... I don't even have words for how amazing it it. I feel completely shell-shocked right now. I mean, it started out and I thought, this is a safe story, for sure. No tears from me this time, I can make it through this.
Then, damn it, I ended up crying SEVERAL times. Sam and Dean dying in the future, future-Dean snuggling with little Sammy and past-Dean (happy tears that time, but still) and don't even get me started on the tears shed when they read that letter... I mean, come on, does EVERYTHING in this fandom have to make me cry? Can't I just read a story in peace, damn it!?
But you know what? The tears (happy, sad, devastated, broken, joyful) were totally worth it for that ending. That ending had me grinning from ear to ear. Seriously, the best thing ever. I love it. I love that they were spared all the death, all the burdens, all the pain and guilt that is the reason I cry so often over this fandom. I love hat they got to have a real family, or as close to one as they possibly could, I love that Dean graduated and is going to college, I love that they're HAPPY.
And most of all... Gabriel :3 Seriously, I love that you included Gabriel. The ONLY possible way to have made this ANY better would have been to include Castiel, which is unfeasable given the AU-ness of the story and the fact that Cas would never have gotten to know the Winchesters in the world.
So, in short, this story was a wonderful read, amazingly written and just so wonderful I can't even wrap my head around it. Absolutely perfect!
(PS- the Whovian in me kept screaming: DON'T TOUCH YOUR PAST-SELF DEAN! YOU'LL CREATE A PARADOX AND RIP OPEN THE UNIVERSE! Hehe. Just thought I'd put that out there, 'cos I couldn't help it.)
Once more, brilliant work! Loved it!
| Callisto-HK chapter 1 . 6/23/2012
ONE word: BRILLIANT!
Thanks for sharing this. It was amazing. :'''D
| BlackKeys96 chapter 1 . 6/20/2012
Beautiful story. I was crying by the end. If only this had happen. Their lives could have been so much better. Thank you for this story. Gah future Dean really had me crying my eyes out. Loved it.
| HeyI'mTalkingToYou chapter 1 . 4/9/2012
mrrrrrgghh I'm bawling. I just want everyone to be happy, but that seems too much to ask from the show these days. But you wrote it so wonderfully, and yet heartbreakingly. Thank you.
| GaelicAngel chapter 1 . 1/11/2012
You know when I started out reading this story I had entirely differant idea of what it was gonna be about but this has completely bowled me over. I loved ever single second of this and the idea behind it was bloody brilliant. Awesome that you gave the boys the happy ending that they finally earned and you kept Gabe alive which was awesome as I love the dude.
This was a terrific read and I loved it, great work!
| Rolletti chapter 1 . 1/9/2012
I am speechless. This story is just amazing, and should be up for an award somewhere. You have done something no one else has, at least from all that I've read, creating a marvelous masterpiece. This will definitely go on my Favorites list. This was done so well...I just don't know what else to say, because the story speaks for itself. Great and wonderful job on a story well done.
Oh wait! I think is was SO COOL that little Sammy figured out that "Adam" was really his Dean grown up. It gave me chills. What also gave me goosebumps on top of goosebumps was the first paragraph of the letter John and Dean read. To have that knowledge presented to them...WOW! I will HAVE to read this story again soon. It's the kind of story that pulls at you until you do.
Thanks for bringing a smile to my face. Again, I LOVE IT!
| nancylou chapter 1 . 1/1/2012
This is how the show should end. Not with Dean and Sam dead, but with one of them going into the past and 'fixing' things.
WeeSammy is a smart cookie, he bonded with 'Adam' right away and then realized who 'Adam' really was. Loved that futureDean still has his other brother in his thoughts.
Everyone is mentioned. From the good (Ellen) to the bad (Gordon) to the ugly (Travis). :) Love.
'S & W Savage', love.
Best of all, everyone lives at the end.
| BranchSuper chapter 1 . 12/25/2011
| Anna chapter 1 . 12/25/2011
OMG, this was utterly fantastic! Dean going back to set things right and preventing all the deaths from happening as well as giving all three Winchesters a chance at a life. I absolutely love this one and it is so going into my favorites! Thank you for sharing this.
| Psychee chapter 1 . 12/25/2011
I loved this story!
| sylia91 chapter 1 . 12/24/2011
Wonderful fic! If only, sigh.