|Reviews for It's the Philosopher's stone, Charlie Brown|
| Laura Jones chapter 5 . 10/17/2013
This is an interesting crossover between the Harry Potter series and Peanuts. I was reading this because I am a fan of both Harry Potter and Peanuts. I was wondering when you will post more chapters. I am curious what will happen next.
| Mathlover15 chapter 7 . 12/13/2012
This is great stuff so please update soon!
| areanna123 chapter 7 . 11/28/2012
| areanna123 chapter 1 . 11/28/2012
Oh, the football. This was great. Normally I don't really like crossovers, but the way this is written makes me feel as if Charlie Brown should have been a wizard in the original. I am going to love seeing the gang in Hogwarts.
| marisa lee chapter 5 . 4/15/2012
Alrighty then, fine with me, it's just that someone posted a review on my story with a request for a peanuts/Pokemon crossover, and I noticed that you had the idea in mind. Since I'm not a super huge Pokemon fan, I figured I could refer them to you. Not really my request, but I help out as I can. The person doesn't have a fanfiction account, that of they aren't logged in. I was going to leave a mention for them in my next chapter. Of course it's entirely up to you if I leave your name or not. Thank you. :)
| marisa lee chapter 7 . 4/15/2012
Hi Tiger Lover, I would like to ask a favor of you, but i can't figure out how to compose a message to you. xP message me when you read this! thanks!
| Dracarot chapter 7 . 4/13/2012
You can't stay here you know, this isn't your common room. Get out!" Said a stout-looking boy named Ernie Macmillan.
Minor correction, Ernie Macmillan is a Hufflepuff, the named male Ravenclaws have been Roger Davies, (Ravenclaws quidditch captain at least up to Order of the Phoenix) Terry Boot, Anthony Goldstein, and Michael Corner (all in Harry's year).
Still a good chapter, though I feel Lucy's little booth needs to be taken down and she herself put in detention for her invasion of the Ravenclaw Common Room. As prefects don't have the necessary skill to deal with her it is now up to a professor.
| supersexyghotmew95 chapter 7 . 4/12/2012
bravo my good man XD
| randompandattack chapter 5 . 4/6/2012
Your story where Charlie Brown is Harry Potter made alot more sense before the actual Harry Potter showed up. You had to change alot of stuff that would've been alot less complicated if you just taken it out entirely. Also if this is the actual harry potter's 2nd year I'm not sure why Quirrel is still here instead of lockhart. I guess i'll read the 6th chapter though.
| marisa lee chapter 6 . 3/25/2012
Great chapter! Here are my points:
- freida and patty are absolutely cruel! Ben they couldn't be that mean...but alas, they are! How terrible ): poor Charlie.
- it would be interesting to know what Charlie sAid in his letter home to Sally!
- I still think Lucy belongs in slytherin, but that's only me /: oh well. I do think she should have some advocacy there, though.
- I absolutely love his penpal. Simply the cutest thing.
- poor snoopy and Woodstock! Always getting in trouble ): oh well, I guess that's what they're all about, huh?
- Your pigpen is so incredibly sweet. A bit different from the pigpen I envision with the comics, but the way you've portrayed him is absolutely adorable. I hope he and luna have a future more-than-friendship! :)
- all in all, an amazingly well written story, save for a few grammatical errors here and there. Try spell check :) please keep up the good work, I'm so excited for the next chapter!
| Dracarot chapter 6 . 3/23/2012
Ah Snoopy's shenanigans, got to love them.
But man Violet and Patty need a serious wake up call.
| supersexyghotmew95 chapter 6 . 3/22/2012
YEAH THIS GETTING JUICY IS THERE LUCY ND SCHROEDER IN THIS XD
| WilliamL chapter 5 . 3/15/2012
I want Snoopy to chase the Bloody Baron, World War I style. Period.
Other than that, the chapter was awesome as always. I can't wait to see what shenanigans our beloved Peanuts kids will get into... XD
Oh, and congratulations on making the longest story in Peanuts fanfiction history!
| marisa lee chapter 1 . 3/13/2012
I definitely agree with everything Ballz Mahoney had to say! vv I really enjoyed this chapter. There are so many things where I wa just reading and all of a sudden, my reaction was, "what just happened? Oh no way!" especially when Lucy wasn't in slytherin! I thought for SURE she would be in there. And when they met Harry, ron and Hermione, Harry's character was so much like his dad's! It took me a while to really process it, but after some thought, I really enjoy this story and you're just telling it how you want to tell it. So please, keep it going. It is definitely one of the best on here.
| Ballz Mahoney chapter 5 . 3/12/2012
This is probably my favorite ongoing story on here currently. I'm still enjoying every second of this and eagerly await more! Both the Peanuts and Harry Potter elements of the story are handled perfectly and you make them mesh very well.
I like how Harry Potter seems a lot more laid back in this story. At first it seemed slightly out of place, but it's perfectly understandable. He'd be a totally different person if he had lived with his parents instead of his aunt and uncle as well as not having to deal with the fame and pressure of being the boy who lived. From the short bit we've seen him he reminds me quite a bit of what we know about his father. Not sure if that's what you were going for or not, but it certainly works well!