|Reviews for For All Our Sakes|
| Jade chapter 1 . 2/11/2012
after seeing the 25th I was a little confused if madame Giry helped the phantom escape or not so ur fic cleared things up for me.
I really hope you write more phantom 25th one shots!
| eponnia chapter 1 . 1/12/2012
This. Is. SOOOOOO. SAD!
I've always wondered what exactly Madame Giry saw at the travelling circus (the 2004 movie's interpertation was fine, but not how I picture it). This is completly the stage version's makeup, and that's why I love it. The deformities for Erik isn't a sunburn/a rash - it's described in minute detail. I really get a sense of Liz Robertson as Giry, and I got a sense of Hadley's Raoul. For Ramin's Phantom, it was harder, because in her memory, Erik is twelve, so it's more touch and go on if it's Ramin's "style." However, the absolute heartbreak I felt made up for anything that I didn't get a sense of. I wanted to shoot the Gypsy. It's so absolutly DEGRADING that he calls Erik "it." And then the reference to Erik's mother didn't even love him...
All in all, VERY GOOD.