Reviews for The North Remembers |
---|
![]() ![]() Killing ghost was not right |
![]() ![]() Forgot to mention, where's Aegon's stone dragon? Did it die too? Can't they sacrifice people with greyscale to wake stone dragons if necessary? Or is the morale that dragons in general are a bad idea? I hope Jon visited Bran Pretty fucked up that Bran would make his nephew go and suffer his fate too |
![]() ![]() ![]() I know the writer said to read all 5 books to read it,, I've watched the tv series but not read the books, can I still read it? |
![]() ![]() Rip Drogon and Viserion. Rhaegal is probably immortal since he is bound to Jon. How the Hell did Tyrion talk Dany into marrying him, lol Dany could've circumvented this fiasco if she talked Jon or Aegon into siring an heir for her, thus saving bothe dragons and saving her kingdom a lot of necessary death that would follow once they're gone. Seems to have been a dumb idea to expect the princess of a deposed regime to make for a good vassal lady, never mind Cersei's daughter. For Jon it seems his ending is very bittersweet too, having to guard the world for eternity |
![]() ![]() So at the end Theon walked off the cliff and drowned? Very very sad. He could have lived with Jeyne |
![]() ![]() You really nailed the bittersweetness aspect of the end with Sam and Arya. Sam lost his only true friends and home, lost everything, but he saved his best friend and the realm and became a brave man. Arya lost everything, her wolf, he memories, even her humanity, as evidenced by Rickon and Robbie being terrified of her, but she still feels love. Funny how three of the six Stark kids became monsters and demigods, four if you include Robb. |
![]() ![]() So we're soon at the end. My real only complaint would be that it's too short, it could have well been thirty chapters longer, the Martells and Dorne in general are underutilized (they barely matter), the ironborn and Euron aren't promininent enough (did Sam really kill Euron AND the Great Other? Sam the Slayer for real) I would've prefered Volantis to Asshai, especially with teleportation being a thing anyway, the slavery, Essos and Meereen plot is dropped completely, the Others could've been around longer and done more damage to the rest of the kingdoms. But what truly matters is that you captured the spirit of a song of ice and fire, and if the books don't continue, this is a good finish to the series for me. |
![]() ![]() Sam was the hidden mvp this whole time, this ending was very LoTR inspired |
![]() ![]() (Sounds of uncontrollable crying) |
![]() ![]() All in all, this fic as good a continuation of the books as anyone can wish for, with some slightly confusing aspects sure (like Myrcella beating Trystane at cyvasse when he was much better in canon or Dany never freeing the slaves of Volantis or King's Landing and Oldtown not suffering from a tsunami while Meereen did, somehow, or there being such crazy tsunamis in the first place) but it's still an amazing fic, and Jaime's send off was great |
![]() ![]() Stannis only smiling when he chooses suicide is so sad. He really is too tired. Poor Davos has to pick up his sword. |
![]() ![]() 9 chapters to the end? What the hell! It feels like it needs 25 more! |
![]() ![]() Locking dragons into the pit in the first proved a terrible idea, locking them into the pit underneath which are caches of wildfire seems suicidal. Man fAegon did what Dany has yet to do in a week. I gotta say, sparing Jaime of all people is crazy, even if you don't care about Aerys or don't wanna kill him to reinforce the lie, Jaime has earned death just by siring the incest kids and crippling Bran alone, which led to the war in the first place. |
![]() ![]() A great chapter! |
![]() ![]() Imagine if Robb was somehow stuck inside the zombie Mountain, a bizarely grim afterlife |