|Reviews for Us|
| AnimeFan2431 chapter 10 . 7/26
Omg, just finished reading this and I have to say one of the best Charles/Eric story I've read ever.(And I've read a lot of them lol) You are a really good writer, once I started reading I couldn't stop, I loved the way the story was set up with the different time jumps, I loved reading them and getting a better insight to the story.
| Guest chapter 10 . 12/6/2014
Love the final statue. And I agree. Even in her most ridiculous incarnations, Mystique is always utterly badass.
Oh My God.
I waited until I finished reading he entire thing before reviewing, since it's marked complete already.
This was amazingly well done.
Excellent at keeping me stuck on the edge of crying for nearly the entire thing. Though that's partly because I got the hints towards the general 'we do this and then we die' aspect early on and having that on top of the other shit piled on them, and the excellently written effects of that shit... Yeah, I'd have been crying miserably several times if the writing hadn't kept me so desperately caught up in the story I couldn't stop even for that- can't see to read if your crying, after all. ;)
Onslaught is officially the most terrifying 'mutant' ever. No more debates. At all. Onslaught gets the top ranking, possibly forever.
Separate, they both always rank awfully high and cause half the debates. But when they are that tightly and perfectly 'clicked'? Amplifying each other?
Yeah, no contest. Ever again. Holy Shit.
Shaw, you ****ed up. Badly. *grumbles incoherently* *rummages for an acceptable image to attach to a target for archery practice*
*bows* Very, very much job well done. I'd offer treats in offering, but they aren't virtual enough to attach here.
| Lizu chapter 10 . 12/2/2014
Congratulations, the story was remarkable and cohesive, not to mention coherent, which is nothing short of a miracle in fanfiction, considering you handled over three different timelines. Take a moment to give a thought to professional writing or world domination for a second; you might have what it takes.
On the other hand, while I'm generally against they-all-die-the-whole-one-of-him-(or two, in this case) endings, the meaning was plain from about halfway through and constantly reinforced since. It's been a delicate, elegant and imminent progression and as much as I didn't like where it was headed, it was believable. As a reader, I got the message that this was not for the angst points, but rather a natural end, seeing as Charles makes no progress towards healing, whatsoever; I admire consistency (again, over three timelines, astounding). For this reason, the epilogue ending fell flat. I like that you gave some hope, but unlike the X-Men 3 ending (yeah, that movie happened) the deaths were not thrown in on a screenwriter's whim after one too many and thus ambiguous endings should not be thrown in just to please the audience.
| blackvelvet-smile chapter 10 . 6/19/2014
This story is a couple of years old but it had me sobbing like a 4 year old by the end. I had to stop multiple times to wipe away the tears. With the sheer amount of emotion with every additional piece of the puzzle revealed is catastrophic. I can see why so many have added this to a favorite's list or recommended it in other stories (which is actually how I came to read it.) It isn't too often that I write a review for a story aged nearly 2 years but this warrants a kudos.
Amazing. Fantastic. A dramatic and emotional read. Spell binding from the first chapter. That's what this story was and much more. Thank you and good luck on everything it is you do. I hope to read more of your fantastic work in the near future.
| Kokoroyume chapter 10 . 5/31/2014
Great story :)
| Mango chapter 2 . 4/6/2014
Okay I am REALLY confused SO I am just going to stop reading it.
| Luizals chapter 10 . 12/2/2013
I didn't want to review but I was seriously forced to because this fic is so amazingly good
| icanhearthedrums chapter 10 . 8/22/2013
OMG! i am crying so hard! any other place i would be bawling my eyes out! but right now i'm at my job and I'm trying my hardest to not look like a crazy person! this story was absolutely amazing! i can't imagine a more perfect ending-you are an astonishingly good writer! can't wait to read more of your stories!
| icanhearthedrums chapter 1 . 8/21/2013
WHOA! what an intense chapter!
| LucyWithoutDiamonds chapter 10 . 8/12/2013
It took a bit to get past all the time skips and sub-plot intertwining, but once I put it all together - wow. This was so absolutely incredible. That ending, the build, just- wow. I want to hug you for writing this. It's the best thing I've read all week. I'll definitely be passing it on.
| princess-oro chapter 10 . 5/23/2013
Oh god this story. How do you write so beautifully, wringing such feelings of happiness and desolation from your readers? This is such an amazing story I had to read it in between classes.
I really liked how you built up the suspense, tantalising us with their secret but never fully revealing it until the end. I had somehow gotten a feeling that this story wouldn't end well for our favourite mutant couple, and I thought I had sufficiently prepared for it but oh lord the blow that you delivered to my heart in the previous chapter. It's really interesting reading about a Charles that's not quite Charles, there's this unnerving sense of callousness and brutality in him that's just so antithetical to his canon self. Yet you presented him in such a believable manner, with his unfortunate circumstances that shaped him to his darker self. And I absolutely love and appreciate the way your story transitions, the flashbacks were very well executed and it had me anticipating yet fearing to read about Charles's captivity.
And that was a very beautiful epilogue. You have such a wonderful writing style, I like how you closed it with Kitty's pov mirroring the beginning of this story. I cannot tell you how much I enjoyed reading this but here's some mental bear hugs for you, thank you thank you so much for writing this gem :)
| Summer Memory chapter 10 . 4/8/2013
My goodness, I really, really love this story. I was hooked from the first chapter and cant stop reading until the end. Your characterization and plot are very impressive.
your Dark!Charles is very broken and lost, and Erik is just desperately trying to piece everything together. Their relationship, their love, after what happens to Charles is bittersweet and sad and gentle. And their last night made me tear up a little when I realize something is very wrong, and it's proven that in the end, they decide to remove themselves from the equation. ... :(
I also want to point out that you're really did a great job in switching scene between the past and present by distinguishing them with details (very, very, very impressive XD) and also selecting the right mind (person/POV) in depicting it thus backing up each character with more solid ground and thoughts.
The plot itself is epic, and you managed to mix the scene with the original timeline, and it's very cool.
I had wished, they could have been together in the end, and I secretly hope that it's Erik doing to the statue at the last chapter...(because I don't really get it, my bad -_-"") and I imagine a scene that somewhere, far away, Charles is comfortably warm, watching the snow outside the window, with Erik holding him both physically and mentally. Just two of them and totally separated from the world...*sigh
I'm sorry for the rambling and the bad language, English is not my native tongue, but I hope that I still could get my message across that I love this story and I love you for writing this story. Wait, that came out wrong, but.
Please keep up the good work! :)
| beccabam chapter 10 . 1/1/2013
This is a beautiful story can't belive you havnt got more views than the ending it was heartbreaking and I love the scene where you have the statue change just amazing, this is my favourite Erik/Charles story thank you for sharing.. xxxx
| Kaylen Cooper chapter 10 . 10/29/2012
I am in awe at this. Speechless.
Absolutely loved it. :)
| RabbidMaki chapter 10 . 10/13/2012
Thanks for this really great fic.
It's really sad for them but at the same time it's really seemed to be the better end.