Oh my god if Irene Adler is a pirate. That would be the death of me!

This must be the tenth time I read this since I found it so many years ago. Still on my top sherlolly AUs. This is one of the few fics I've read that I sometimes think about at night and it struck me to reread it. It is that amazing. THANK YOU

Hands down one of the best stories in Sherlolly universe. Fantastic, awesome, great, the best. Reading it was utter joy and pleasure. Thank you for sharing your skills

I am loving this AU and the way you write the characters. Sherlock is just...I LOVE HIM. And he's so very him too. I want to pat John on the head for being such a good bloke. And I'm wildly interested in what Molly is like in this AU, it's a very interesting setup. Also is Basil the cabin-boy a shout-out to Basil of Baker Street?

By far my favorite fanfic. Such amazing characterization and details. Plus such a well built and rich romance at the center of a really compelling plot.

A wonderful adventure!

Nooo! Foolish girl, now he knows too much. But how could she do nothing?

Oh man. I keep hoping another ship will pop up out of nowhere. Like Mycroft and Matthias? Or that there’s some connections to the two Greek people you’ve mentioned... Melas, the mole and B Team?

I wish I had been reviewing all along, I have so much to say... But this is amazing and I live it!

Loved it. Never really read any PirateLock but I’m Soooooo glad I found this one!

I would like you to know I found this fic... six years ago I think and I reread it whenever I get the chance because I still think it's one of the best pieces I've read. You did a marvelous job! I hope to many more years of rereading this wonderful story.

oooh Greg and John are too bloody cute

Everything is awesome and nothing hurts! I've enjoyed this story so much I can't even describe it. Sherlock as a pirate, not an ordinary pirate, but a scientist-pirate, is everything. John and Greg are an unusual couple, but they work beautifully together. And Moriarty and Moran were suitably chilling, because of course Jamie wouldn't be a regular old booty-hunting pirate. And Molly is the perfect morbid, adorable pirate queen. Really well done!

Very lovely read. I usually don't review at all but I thought after spending the past week reading this fic off and on you deserve it. Great job!

What a great story! Thanks)

That was AWESOME! Just sayin.