Reviews for A Marauder's Plan
ZXcSzxfc chapter 36 . 1/18
so stations of canon despite your attempts to hide it? cringe bad and unoriginal writing
UnClinical chapter 26 . 1/2
Cringe. All can be said. An author should be impartial. Well a good one i suppose, an absolute garbage one doesnt it seems. Then 99.9% fanfics with their false illogical "cherry morality" prove to me that despite all her faults, Rowling is actually a better person tha most on earth. A staggeringly depressing thought since i co sider has about as moral as Hitler.

Back to the story: Its anothrr Harry Potter K- pretending Teen or Mature, while in reality being basically... What if DOLORES UMBRIDGE wrote Harry Potter not Rowling.
Its all pink, full of deus ex machinas and offers exactly ZERO tension or actual magic beyond idiot authors made up spells that dont fit cos arent greek or lating but willy wonka english like: Bananas Aplentias or Housus Magikus Protectus Harus Potterus For Lifus Fromus Allus Plotus.

Also Dumbledore and Ron bashing cks of course the idiot author who thinks himself a good person does that ;p love how author is anti-bullying but will bully imaginary characters he doesnt like ;p fucking two faced shits of this world.
IamNOTawriter chapter 87 . 1/1
Thanks for a well-written and entertaining story.
CoolFanfictionLover chapter 87 . 1/3
my favorite story
libbyxox1 chapter 87 . 12/11/2024
this is the second read through for me. i enjoyed it just as much as the 1st.

great story !
hallowedmaiden chapter 87 . 12/7/2024
I really loved this story.

I only have two criticisms that I feel strongly about.

One, Harry felt like a side/background character for a lot of the story. He kind of just...was meh. I would have made the majority of the P.O.V from Harry's perspective, with a few smatterings here and there of only Sirius, Hermione, Voldemort, and Dumbledore. I just didn't really get the full "Harry Potter becomes independent of Dumbledore and is super powerful" because he really seemed to depend on Sirius way too much, and he still acts like an angsty teenager. Sometimes he is annoying to read.

The other issue I had was that a lot of things seemed to happen off-screen. Like, usually when Sirius or any other character had a scene where they should have reacted to something important, we didn't get the scene, and instead had them just talking about the event later on with a different character. I kept wanting to read the actual reactions in the moment only to find out that I wasn't going to get to.

The only other minor thing was that I felt like Hannah was shoe-horned in as a later development instead of being planned from the beginning to betray Harry. There wasn't really any sort of hint that Barty was manipulating a female minor (from his POV), and the story didn't really give any subtle hints that it was happening. It should have.

The rest of the story was well written and fun to read. I hope you do write a sequel someday.
Angelinia chapter 87 . 11/14/2024
Wonderful story, with great writing. I've really enjoyed the journey and wish it didn't have to end.

The only downside was some time confusion during the first summer; it would have been helpful with more dates at the start, like you did later on. Also, the time bubble could maybe be listed as Day 1, etc, rather than an actual date, as that was truly confusing.

Otherwise, thank you very much for a great story, which manages to be unique despite loosely following the canon framework. Keep up the good work
tumshie chapter 1 . 10/25/2024
Do you know someone is posting your story as a podcast on AO3?
ayame992 chapter 87 . 10/23/2024
Thank you for this story! It's unique and well written! A complex story, that I really recommend! Thanks again!
Guest chapter 1 . 10/20/2024
Hounoku — Today at 17:18
Guys do not say gaymar and replace the gay part with cred
Worst mistake of my life

Very cute Hounoku. Very cute ;)
Fortunately I'm not some faggot gay latino or some shit skinned turd worlder as Mahogany mentioned. Imagine being one, born into a shithole family with shithole beliefs and shithole ideals its no wonder that many latinos and black niggers and slant eyed chink face Chinese could never hope to assimilate into American culture to achieve the coveted American dream. Instead I see these scum as nothing more than a waste of oxygen and as infiltrators like wannabe spies that will soon disappear when Trump gets into power. Alternatively if the author of Summoning America, Sebastian Lee were to run for President I'd vote for him in a heartbeat since in the story there are no blacks niggers gays homosexuals trannies Muzzies and Jews ruining America by staining the white genepool with their inferior genes. The only honorable brown skinned turd I respect is Peconigiri since he is helping me identify people who slander DrDoritosMD's work from afar like the cowards they are. So far I am able to determine that most of them live in the turd world and at least one lives in some shithole called Jogjakarta or some shit name its so easy to bribe with the superior dollar compared to the rupee curee fag currency they use. The Dutch should've exterminated everyone except for Peconigir's lineage because it is clear people like him and Gomrade are honorary Americans for how they carry themselves. Its okay when the Chinks led by winnie the pooh declare war we will let the turd world be exterminated by AliExpress nukes and then with the slate clean the white race can finally reclaim our lost and rightful home to expand.

**Manifest Fantasy on Royal Road – A Step Toward Bestselling Achievement!**

Hello, Fantasy Enthusiasts and Readers,

We’re excited to share some incredible news about "Manifest Fantasy," the captivating story by the talented DrDoritosMD! This engaging adventure is gaining momentum on Royal Road, and we’d like to take a moment to reflect on its remarkable journey and bright future!

In "Manifest Fantasy," Captain Henry Donnager's humble role at Area 51 takes an unexpected turn when a test inadvertently opens a portal to a realm filled with knights, magic, and political intrigue. Leading Alpha Team, he must navigate a complex web of politics and powerful sorcery while balancing his own world’s advanced technology with the ancient secrets of this new land. Can they unlock the mysteries of this enchanting world before rival factions clash?

As we celebrate this exciting milestone, we are also delighted to announce that DrDoritosMD is on the cusp of securing a publishing deal! This brings us one step closer to sharing "Manifest Fantasy" with an even larger audience, and we truly believe it has the potential to become a bestseller. With its intricate world-building, thrilling quests, and unforgettable characters, this tale is one to cherish.

Join us in supporting DrDoritosMD as we look forward to a future where "Manifest Fantasy" can enchant readers around the globe. Dive into this adventure on Royal Road today, and let’s make this journey an unforgettable one together!

Happy reading!

Explore the story here: fiction/75057/manifest-fantasy?sortingoldest

Support the author through these links:
Patreon - drdoritosmd
Twitch - .tv/drdoritosmd
Webull Stock Analysis Referral Link - KFgi6zkc37slwnlyGR
Oracle Analytics for Investment advice - t/ZT8Y95uQt/
dixonjason403 chapter 56 . 10/14/2024
harry is a child so his behavior is kinda expected, but he's so goddamn whiny and immature at times, even for his age. after all, just because its in character doesnt mean its not obnoxious to read. #HarryIsLameAsFuckSometimes
dixonjason403 chapter 53 . 10/14/2024
Im kinda getting a bit sick of this story. None of the buffs to the good guys matter at all, because you just arbitrarily made the bad guys even stronger, and made everything that happens more dangerous. the entire premise of this story has kinda been spoiled since you REFUSE to let the good guys gain any actual advantage, you just keep moving the goalposts. This is just canon except everyone on both sides is equally stronger, theres no real point to it. #BadWriting
dixonjason403 chapter 52 . 10/14/2024
yay, blatant unfair interference. fantastic. right off the bat this tournament is already more bullshit than the books. #KindaLame
dixonjason403 chapter 47 . 10/13/2024
so ive kinda realized that pretty much EVERY child character in this story outside of harry, and a bit or hermione, draco, and neville is just...irrelevant filler. just side characters whose presence adds nothing to the story besides filling a spot. #KidsAreFuckinUseless
dixonjason403 chapter 46 . 10/13/2024
honestly the goblet as a plot device is stupid. its an artifact that can somehow magically bind CHILDREN without their knowledge, consent or presence, and kills the kid if they want out of the bullshit they didnt even sign up for . its a fucking dark artifact.

lets be real, the plot has to bend over backwards to not only make him participate, but also stop him from sandbagging or giving up like fleur did in round 2 in the books. its a giant mess of contrived writing, and no matter what its not going to be good. this story is trying its best to work around just how bad the writing in the book was, and its not really succeeding (i think it impossible for ANYONE to fix), but goddamn do i at least applaud the monumental effort the author is putting in.

#TheMagicCupIsFuckinStupidAndWeHateIt
12,464 | Page 1 2 3 4 11 .. Last Next »