|Reviews for Wisp|
| SpaztasticNerd chapter 21 . 11/2
This is in no way a criticism but damn this all sucks! (as a frustrated reader)
It hurts so much every time they call her Wisp, even though the dont have another name to call her, but its like naming her after the worse version of herself! it makes me sad, but I get it.
And then during the pelvic exam! Plying her with candy, telling her its ok even though she doesnt think it is! The candy thing is something abusers do to children, its just so hard when the actions theyre doing "to" her are actually for her health.
I am so obsessed with this story rn.
| Agsters chapter 63 . 8/16
I’ve had this story on my to-read list for a while, (particularly because the word count scared me, haha) Because fanfics with this high of a word count tend to be a hit or miss. But my gosh, when I tell you I finished this story in a recordbreaking 24 hours WITHOUT doing any of my notorious skimming over large bodies of text….. I COULD NOT put it down! As a psych major so much of the content resonated with my studies and what I’ve learned but also, so much resonated with me as just being a female human being. I loved the way WispEdward’s relationship progressed, while keeping the plot, her conditions and overall events fairly realistic. It’s a dark and scary world but I hold on to the hope that there are people like your Edward, Esme, Rose, Alice etc. for any and all the possible Wisps out there. Incredible writing, incredible amounts of knowledge has been put into this story! Stories like this are what keep my passion for reading fanfic alive. Amazing!
| Puzzler54 chapter 63 . 7/18
Wow what a deep, tragic but also beautiful story. I've hardly put my phone down in days! I'm glad there was a gap at the end before things changed. It. Even though the relationship was what it was, it wouldn't have been appropriate for it to have gone any further.
You definitely made me cry many a time but particularly when Ed cried when he found her upside down (no spoilers for readers but hopefully this makes sense to the author). Thank you for sharing the deep story.
| Guest chapter 63 . 4/15
Okay, no seriously, when did Edward fall in love with her because she was his ward. He had a duty of care. There is no way he could just be with her after she got better this fast. Bella didn't even know who Bella was until the final chapter.
He should have let someone else take responsibility the second his feelings became sexual.
Edward just kept doing whatever he wanted in regards to Bella, taking advice only when it suited him. He didn't even get training for how to take care of Bella, so he was essentially grooming Bella.
As for Bella she learnt how to manipulate Edward because of the way he spoiled her. She may have matured and become of sound adult mind, but she was a spoilt one. No amount of trauma makes that okay.
And Edward spoilt Bella because he was never able to let go of the guilt he felt when he found her. How she was in the truck during poker. Edward himself should have gotten therapy. It seems his inability to say no Bella is the reason they hooked up in the end. Again, was that because of guilt? The unresolved emotions from that night or knowing what Bella experienced? Refusing to say no because of her experiences? If anything he should have said no to teach her boundaries. To teach Bella that no doesnt always have to be bad. No doesnt mean punished.
How to use no properly.
Edward and Bella should not have ended up together. They would have been better as friends in the end. Even brother and sister would have been better.
| Guest chapter 63 . 4/15
I read this story years ago. I dont know if I had read the ending. It was a Wip back then.
I have to say, while its well written, the ending is really problematic. I feel like Edward and Bella only ended up together because are Edward and Bella.
In this case I don't think that should have happened. It just feels really wrong. Maybe a few years down the line when Bella has lived and learnt more about life. Had a chance to explore and know herself more. Met new people outside the Cullens and people helping her.
May in a sequel... that way we get to see Bella become Bella not just because of Tanya.
Good writing otherwise.
| assimpleasthat chapter 63 . 11/18/2022
So tragic but at the same time beautiful. My heart ached all the time reading this, I couldn't help it, to be in Bellas shoes…not gonna lie i had to stop reading it for a while.
| Just Sus chapter 63 . 8/21/2022
I read this story long ago when it was a WIP. I forgot what a hauntingly tragic, yet beautiful story it was. Your writing is so succinct, and I can't tell you how many times I cried, and laughed!
The future take was good... Bella is an amazing survivor! I do wish there had been a Wisp-POV of the 1st time she and Edward made love. I think that would have been interesting to hear from her.
I hope, over these past years since this unique story was written, that you have been able to overcome your own demons, and found a happy and peaceful life! Thank you for this incredible story. Sending light and love to you, Sus...
| Just Sus chapter 28 . 8/19/2022
OH MY GOD!
| Just Sus chapter 27 . 8/19/2022
Why doesn't he marry her? Then no one could f'ck with them!
| Shannon Susan32 chapter 63 . 8/10/2022
I completely love your story. I’m a licensed psychologist and everything you underlined is so true. It gutted me in places. The story moved along beautifully. I don’t have the words to describe how amazingly aching this story is. Thank you.
| friesforfive chapter 1 . 8/2/2022
Thank you for sharing your work with us! I really enjoyed the relationship between Pet and Bella
| friesforfive chapter 48 . 8/2/2022
I know it’s been a hot second but reading your AN for this chapter inclines me to sayhello, I hope you’re doing lovely and well, and thank you for your service in offering these stories to all of us out here in the FF world. Sending much love.
| cocoapurl chapter 63 . 6/30/2022
This story was beautiful. Thanks for writing it. :)
| cocoapurl chapter 3 . 6/25/2022
This is one of the most well-written fanfictions I've read over the years. I'm enjoying it.
| cocoapurl chapter 2 . 6/25/2022
I love your writing. It's heartbreaking what she's going through. However, I'm wondering why neither Edward nor Carlisle called the police? The ambulance I can understand because Carlisle's a doctor and he could care for her until she was presentable. But, it seems like the longer they wait the more likely James will be long gone.