|Reviews for Wishing Is Cold This Year|
| Stoney Angel chapter 1 . 2/8
This is really great. I love Cas struggling with the enigma that is Sam Winchester! Not so black and white after all. And I think Sam's brother is wrong about him quite often, too lol! xo
| shookenuppepsi chapter 1 . 8/20/2013
"You fell for Dean, but Sam can teach you how to be human."
Wow. That's just huge. This whole fic was like one heart-wrench after another and I just wanted Cas to grow some balls and say he was sorry, but I can't help but love this.
| staidwaters chapter 1 . 5/9/2013
This is beautiful writing- socked me in the gut but in a good way
| isabelincoln chapter 1 . 4/5/2013
I absolutely loved this, especially since, at least from my perspective, SPN writers seem to forget Sam and Cas are friends too. But I loved how you wrote Cas and his thoughts on Sam. And I also loved that line, "Castiel hung up so he did not inform Dean rather sharply that someone WAS." Absolute brilliant work!
| lillelouis chapter 1 . 1/7/2013
Why... Are there no second chapters to ANY of these? Are you flipping kidding me?!
| Tears of Eternal Darkness chapter 1 . 7/12/2012
That was a nice, interesting take on the brothers separation. I'm starting to enjoy Sam/Castiel friendship fics more and more. -
| T.L. Arens chapter 1 . 5/21/2012
"You fell for Dean, but Sam can teach you how to be human."-That's the best line in the whole story and it was like a nail hit me between the eyes. Castiel seemed so cold and detatched and yet something inside motivated him to stay with Sam. I thought it was really wonderful how you wrote of Castiel's lack of experience and inability to fully understand why he did what he did. certainly it was not because he had nothing better to do. Logically, as Dean said in an earlier episode (season 7) angels just aren't equipped to completely understand motivation, emotion or the reason for either. Your story here demonstrates that beautifully. And yet you left room for the possibility that they can be taught. People don't grow up automatically knowing how to talk, they have to learn. I think the same goes for Angels.
I also love how you ended the story-or rather did not end it. You left some of it open to personal interpretation and the possibility for a continuance of story; the relationship (or lack thereof) between Dean and Sam. Very nicely done. :)
| Leighta Greenleaf chapter 1 . 5/12/2012
Wonderful! (Not the Sam getting his ass kicked and demon blood forced down this throat)
I've been a little disappointed at the show for not showing any sort of development in Cas and Sam's relationship. It always seemed to me that Cas and Sam, in less 'apocalyptic' circumstances, would be two peas in a pod since they both are more the scholarly/nerdy type.
| Red River chapter 1 . 5/12/2012
I liked this story a lot; it always seemed a shame to me that after Sam and Dean split, Castiel didn't seem to even know where Sam was - especially since Sam was having a hard time on his own. Your story was very well-written, and walked the line between bitter and sweet perfectly for this point in the series. I like the way you wrote the interaction between Sam and Cas, too. Their friendship is touching and very meaningful here. Thanks for a good story - I hope to see more from you soon.
| kirallie chapter 1 . 5/9/2012
| BranchSuper chapter 1 . 5/6/2012
Very good story.
| Rokhal chapter 1 . 5/6/2012
Wow, Castiel is such a passive-aggressive little biatch in this. "You don't want to hear about Sam? You will not hear about Sam. Enjoy some radio silence."
Castiel seems so alien in this - just picking his allegiances off a list, a list that consists of Dean - until the story unfolds a bit and I recognize his behavior as something children do before they learn to understand that other people have their own families. It's fascinating how he spends so much time and attention figuring out how to help Sam, while barely expressing concern until the very end. I can just watch their teeny little half-friendship grow up from nothing at the start of the fic.
This is so nuanced, profound, rational, subtle . . . I'm gonna fave this one, too. Makes me glad to be in this fandom.
| AlxM chapter 1 . 5/6/2012
OMG! Great story, I really enjoyed it! I enjoyed a lot of your stories. Since I have red most of them. I'm planning on reading all of them. LOL! Ooh, so this isn't actually completed yet? Does this mean that there's more? :) Thank you!
| SupernaturallyEgocentric chapter 1 . 5/6/2012
| SPN Mum chapter 1 . 5/6/2012
I really enjoyed the dynamics between Sam and Cas. I always wanted to see Cas realize just how much more there was to Sam, than what the other angels saw. Sam didn't choose to have the demon blood, he didn't choose to be Azazel's 'golden boy', and he certainly never wanted to be Lucifer's chosen vessel. All things evil wanting to make him a part of their 'plan', yet always trying to do good, no matter the cost to him. You did an awesome job of showing that.
Please say that this will be continued. I would love to see more.