While I feel for Bella, Edward was very clear in telling her from the very beginning and throughout their relationship that he didn’t want her to wait for him and did not do long term relationships. And while that might seem cruel he was being honest and it’s actually great that he is being so open and transparent about how he feels. I think Edward could have been nicer aBout the entire situation but ultimately Bella decided to stay with him knowingly

I’m sad she’s waited all these months for him! I was hoping she would jump back into the daring world to show Edward she has many more options than just him!

It seems like Bella understood the agree but still wanted more from Edward the entire time which is interesting, I feel like she should have broken it off before this point but hey that would be a boring story lol

Edward has such a big ego in this story wooow glad Bella can hold her own

Wow Edward’s pov is different than I expected, he’s not the decent guy I thought, I knew he was a player but his thoughts are so off putting with “wanting to test Bella out tonight”

So sweet of Charlie to do all that for Bella. Wonder where he got all that money for it and if it’s relevant to the story. I have to wonder how living above a bar would be, I’d imagine very loud until they close early in the am

You know me, I like to reread this story every year, and every time it makes me cry. Still one of the greatest stories I've ever read, and I'll forever be grateful to you for writing it.

Awesome...

Awesome story! I would only Charlie passing away and Rose being hurt but that is life, without lows we wouldn’t have highs. Thanks so much for sharing.

I’m looking forward too the big reveal with everyone, his parents and Jasper the most.

Wow...
I was sorry Bella wasn’t pregnant.
I’m sorry Charlie passed.

Bella knew Leah’s story and should have knew exactly Leah’s connection from the beginning. She was asking have you seen him, have you heard anything.

Ohhhh shit! I know it can’t end that way.

I think Bella is being a selfish whinny baby. She agreed to wait until his contract is up, she can’t take that back because he got a job offer. Edward’s whole life is fishing, Bella trying to change him will not work out well, relationships take compromise.
What’s happening to Charlie is awful but it is not Edward’s responsibility to change jobs to take care of him, or to support Bella while she does. Not that he doesn’t care or shouldn’t help where he can.

I was really hoping he would beat the cancer, very sad.