Reviews for I am the Other
kksambo chapter 5 . 1/18
I'm sorry, but she's pathetic! Almost 15 years worth of abandonment and she's not even a speck angry. It doesn't make sense. Not mention how unrealistic her forgiveness is toward her dad. And there wasn't even a speck of resentment or jealousy towards the brothers who got to be raised by their dad without her. Also fucking unrealistic. No, its just like this "hey you abandoned me young and I grew up alone, but lets pretend everything's fine. And Sam and Dean, there isn't a drop of jealousy I feel that you got to be raised with dad together without me, and I don't resent you for not trying to find me, ever." TOTALLY. FREAKING. UNREALISTIC. Also, she's weak. She cries every five seconds. Whines about her crappy life and is irrationally attached to her brothers. For a grown ass woman, and certainly a Hunter, she's weak and her character is an equivalent to an angsty 12 year old.
Guest chapter 6 . 1/2
Alright, 5 and a half chapters in and i had to stop. At first when i found this is was like wow, this is pretty well written for having so little reviews. Soooo i read. Not bad. Then we get to the second chapter. Dean and Sam see her for the first time after, what, 4 years? And they barely even acknowledge it. No, hey, what the HELL have you been doing, or WHY the Hell you've been gone so long, but no, she comes skippy doo da back into their lives like nothin ever happened, and there are no ill feelings towards her, shit, if i were to skip not even 10 paragraphs it's like she's been there that whole time, skippy doo da. Just unrealistic. But, i kept reading, thinking maybe the writer just didn't want to write out all the blah blah (even though it's very necessary blah blah). So i read, and it's alright. Although the lack of 4 years separated is disregarded entirely. And i get to chapter 5. Dean and Sam meet their sissy's boyfriend. Lol. There is noooo wayyy in hell they would be skippy doo da with any guy fuckin their lil sis. And the fact that he's a hunter? Dean would haaaate that. Idk. Just none of these characters are deep enough, and none of them have the reactions that they should have, if you correlate to their drama on the show. Ima stop readin this now. It's so long, and i really hate to think that you've got writing talent but u just keep writing so...WRONGLY. Kudos to my vocab, anyway. Cheers, bb i hope you've had some sort of epiphany.
supernaturalgirl96 chapter 67 . 5/25/2014
You made me cry again... :( FANTASTIC chapter
BurnThoseEyesBlue chapter 66 . 5/8/2014
I reaLLY like this story! I hope you aren'r going to leave it at this! Also, I was wondering if you were eventually going to make it Destiel, at times it seemed like it. WHatever you do I'm gonna look forward to it though!
shadowwolves11 chapter 12 . 8/7/2013
khooo chapter 61 . 7/23/2013
I've been reading/obsessing over this fic for the past week. Can't wait to readi more. I loved the last original chapter. I'd love to read more with Jamie/AJ.
CBloom2 chapter 60 . 5/26/2013
A great take on one of my most favourite episodes. Good job x
Emilyrose475 chapter 59 . 5/20/2013
WearyPanda chapter 55 . 3/28/2013
treehillgirl119 chapter 1 . 3/17/2013
Wow, i'll i have to say is that prologue drew me in. I can't wait to read the rest.
Guest chapter 49 . 3/7/2013
Dude, I can't wait for Sam AND Jamie to meet Benny!
jamtammie chapter 1 . 3/7/2013
My name is Jamie, so reading this is extremely weird for me :)
DontWannaBeAClue chapter 47 . 2/7/2013
ACK! You end it there?! Crazy Cas with Jamie and baby... Hmm this could get interesting. Love how you worked her into the story line as a prophetess, only sort of understanding the word of God. Can't wait to see what you come up with next.
Jordan Lynn 7 chapter 46 . 1/28/2013
dang. That took forever to read! and I loved every second of it! ) can't wait for the next chapter.
Shorty22133 chapter 46 . 1/28/2013
Amazing! Love it! Fantastic! Can't wait to see what happens next! Keep it up! :)
38 | Page 1 .. Last Next »