It was quite good. Follow up please, who does Amy get with now?

oh God! you and damalur (who wrote such an eviscerating Sheldon-side of Shenny pining I thoughtterribly mistakenly I'm afriadthat I could handle this oneshot of yours. and then you go and nearly make me cry dammit!)will be the death of me! after putting me through the wringer, then the grinder, then the incinerator, you expect me to rise from the ashes without checking if i were a phoenix (yup. obviously you tore me up REAL GOOD and FINE and i'm supposed to frakkin believe this is your frakkin first time?) God, after your fic, i can't believe that i even doubted i had a heart and that it can be hurt this much. but i'm not sure i want you (or anyone) to fix it. you are just that damn good (sorry it took me a very long ass tangent to get to that but hey, can you blame me?after what you put me through? thanks to you, i now see the appeal of drama/angst. God I am so doomed hahaha)

Wow...just wow. Loved the characterization of Amy. Thanks so much

Both your stories, whilst in some ways similar, left me very tears and oh so touched. Heartbreakingly beautiful.

For someone whose' name is JustSmile1 you sure have a way with making me cry with this one and "i'm still here, all that's left". Great story. :) Dem feels. :'(

Aww! Your fic is so sweet! I loved it!

This was AMAZING. I love sheldon/penny pairings and this one blew me away. Great job :)

Well done! Hard to believe its your first. Hope there will be more!

This is your first BBT fic? It's fantastic! looking forward to more from you!

This was your first BBT fanfic? Wow - I hope it won't be your last because it was very well done. All characters were very much 'in character'. And I especially hope you consider doing more Sheldon/Penny fics as I really enjoy their dynamic. Great job!

How in the WORLD is this your first? This fic is the better than probably around 3/4 of the fics that I've read! (and that is a lot!) I certainly hope that you make more. We need more angst-y Shenny fics around here!

Good job! I love the flow of the story, especially the apartment scene with Sheldon suddenly confronting her. Sheldon is a hard character to do, and you did well. I also liked your protrayal of Raj. Keep up the good work.

That was a great story, i was really worried for most of it i thought it was going to be depressing and have a sad ending, i was so relieved when Sheldon turned up in Penny's apartment, loved the ending

I loved your protrayal of Sheldon. He was just as I can see him - feeling something and yet clueless of his feelings. And that Penny would do that for Amy was exactly right. And that Amy would walk away for Penny was right too. A lovely story. Thank you for it and I hope you do more - an even longer one next time.

"This is non-optional."

PERFECT STATEMENT.

I really loved this fic. Angst-fests are my baby. This...ah. Love it. Love love love it.

This story is a little bit perfect;)