|Reviews for promise not to promise anymore|
| EowynPevensie90 chapter 1 . 7/8
I love this so much! It was written so well and is such a wonderful window into Gwen's mind. Also, I must say, I'm very impressed with the characterization of Peter at the end there. Very film accurate if you ask me. A lot of the time it feels either like the author is really forceing his awkwardness level and his stuttering tendencies or they just ignore it. But it felt really natural in this story. I also loved the memories of Captain Stacy. I really liked him and was sort of sad we didn't get to see more of him before he died. But my favorite thing about this entire fic was this sentace: "Peter doesn't have the capacity to not give his everything; she knows that the same way she knows that the blue sky isn't really blue at all, but an illusion of refracted light." Brilliant. Truly.
| Guest chapter 1 . 5/16/2014
I loved this, you're a great writer. :)
| Mercurial Fire chapter 1 . 8/4/2013
Ah, this is great, and I love it. The interaction between them was so gritty and angsty, and Gwen's thoughts seem so conflicted, and that just makes it all so real.
| Reactionary Response chapter 1 . 5/23/2013
This is beautiful and intelligent and everything I wish I could do with my own writing. Thank you!
| Gyreflight chapter 1 . 5/13/2013
That was the story I needed to read after watching the film, and didn’t find until now.
It reads true. Beautifully written, entirely believable, and emotionally cathartic. Gwen deserves to be taken seriously, to be furious, to grieve, and hurt and feel and love and choose, because her inner world is shattered while the outer one rolls on, because the person who could have helped anchor her against it all /isn’t there/, because no reason is as important as that truth…and forgiveness doesn’t negate it.
You did a beautiful job of fleshing out her character in this, as well as giving her the right to her own emotions, her own choices, and the memories of a father which make him three dimensional too. She and Peter together are painful and fragile and tender…but again, they read true.
Thanks for the read – impressive writing.
| Flip the Hourglass chapter 1 . 3/22/2013
You know what? I think I love you too. At least I love your words. Gahhhhhh. I should be cleaning but here I am, listening to your words reverberating in my head, slithering down down down until they reach my heart and land there with a thump, pushing, pulling it, being it. My heart belongs to your words now. Not you. I mean, not that I don't think you'd be a nice person or anything...but yeah. Your words. I hope this isn't too weird.
| thedreamthieves chapter 1 . 3/21/2013
"It's just that she wouldn't mind the rain so much if he were there to keep her from drowning."
I say words are beautiful a lot but this is one the times I completely MEAN it. Everything about this is emotional and raw and real and perfect. It made me cry about twenty different times. I can't explain how subtly incredible it is. Just- keep writing.
| Addielicious chapter 1 . 3/9/2013
I loved this story! That was so beautiful!
| CrazyAce'n'PokerFace chapter 1 . 2/27/2013
severely awesome. i loved it. :)
| Melika Elena chapter 1 . 1/18/2013
Gorgeous! You captured all of their chemistry in the film with words. Absolutely perfect and heartbreaking.
| TheGhoulNebula chapter 1 . 1/3/2013
Oh no, my feels.
| wild wolf free17 chapter 1 . 12/7/2012
Oh, this is perfect.
| countrygirl1989 chapter 1 . 11/15/2012
| deews chapter 1 . 11/5/2012
OKAY. So, 1: LOOK who finally is not the worst friend in the world anymore!
And 2: Wow, Leah. Just. Ouch? I'm never good at this, because I get kind of emotionally attached to things, but whatever. Here we go.
I love that you have made Gwen as ANGRY as she is in the film, that you didn't back away from that. That you let her HAVE that. Because of COURSE she would be angry-at her father, at Peter, at everything. Of course she would. And I think it's incredibly nuanced that you note WHY she's angry at her father. It's not because he's dead; he was a cop. She always knew that this was part of his job. But it's because in his last moments he could have said anything, and what he chose to say was something that would take Peter away. It's not, in this moment, about Peter; it's about fathers and daughters. She's mad that Peter was gone, but more than that, she's mad that it was HER FATHER who made him be gone.
And I love, love, LOVE that you didn't let Peter's "promises" statement just wash everything away. Because uhhh, Peter? no.
AND LASTLY: the thing about the college applications was perfect perfect perfect perfect perfect.
| rebe2018 chapter 1 . 9/17/2012
so goood aaaaaaaaah