|Reviews for Far Beyond a Promise Kept|
| MargaritaS chapter 17 . 7/17
so good :)
| Randi chapter 17 . 7/14
I love this story. It puts a wonderful new twist on Harry's life following him blowing up Aunt Marge, without taking out the main points. I love it! And, it means neither Dumbledore or Dobby die, not to mention everyone else. Thank you for such an amazing read. -
| WriterJace chapter 17 . 7/15
This is one of my favourite stories. Especially the part where Snape shows Harry his Death Eater uniform is one that really stands out to me in its brilliance!
| Geriana chapter 17 . 7/14
Thank you. This is a gift I could never repay.
| evans137 chapter 17 . 6/16
What a wonderful story! Pity it only has 17 chapters, I would have liked to read many more :-) Any chance you'll write, at least a short, sequel?
I loved how Snape's and Harry's relationship developed and how you pictured Snape - he was still very much in character but with a soft side as well ;-) And what a genius he was by switching Riddle's father's bones with basilisk Bones. I loved that idea!
| Hektols chapter 17 . 6/2
Good ending for a good story.
| Hektols chapter 16 . 6/2
Great way to defeat Voldemort.
Agree with Fudge's idea to keep everything secret, people won't panic and Harry won't have more unwanted attention.
| Hektols chapter 15 . 6/2
Snape's mother was supposed to be dead, I think that it would have been better if Harry talked with a portrait of her.
| Hektols chapter 14 . 6/2
Good point fixing Harry's eyes, if magic can regrow bones then that shouldn't be a problem.
| Hektols chapter 13 . 6/2
Nice that they predicted part of Voldemort's plan and are preparing for it.
| Hektols chapter 12 . 6/2
Very good, specially the bonding.
| Hektols chapter 11 . 6/2
| E-Vector chapter 6 . 6/1
There are greatcircles between any two points on Earth*. So I don't really get what's going on with this-but it does make sense, if you can sense the direction someone Apparates, to follow it in a greatcircle path. And it does make sense to draw greatcircles on a map for that purpose, since Britain is way off of the equator so the directions of greatcircles wouldn't be obvious on a flat map.
*Or there would be if it was a perfect sphere; and if you're not using that approximation I'm pretty sure you're left with only the equator and longitude lines as other geodesics don't close up into circles/ovals.
Anyway, I'm enjoying this story!
| Hektols chapter 10 . 6/1
| Hektols chapter 9 . 6/1
Good work, specially Harry getting closer to Snape.